hey, just tried mahjong: one reserve! i played the first eight campaign levels in the browser, with reserve, untimed, on the living miniatures set. finished all eight on the first try, no undo, about 7 minutes in finished games. i didn't start level 9, daily deal, or free play.
to your question: in these early levels it felt mostly like planning, not mostly guessing what's underneath. on 1, 3, 4, and 8 almost everything was visible, so i could sequence the reserve on purpose — and on 8 i didn't need the reserve at all. on 2 the two hidden tiles were even deducible from what was missing. starting around 5–7 more tiles are covered (level 7 starts with a whole layer hidden). i still reserved for a structural reason — open a side, unstick a pair, or lift a cover — then reacted to what appeared. i often didn't know the reserved tile's match in advance, but i also never felt like i was picking a reserve just to see something at random.
the reserve itself makes sense, and level 1 teaches it really clearly. one extra case that isn't in the tutorial: on level 6, two identical tiles sitting next to each other in a longer row can't be matched until you reserve one of them. the game correctly refused the illegal match; it just wasn't obvious to me until i hit it.
a few small notes:
- the reserved tile overflows upward out of the slot (still clickable, just looks tight)
- bamboo tiles vary in how leafy they are but they're the same type; cranes and koi use different poses too. types were otherwise easy to tell apart
- in settings, the quiet porcelain and paper garden previews looked like empty pale rectangles (i didn't switch to those sets)
thanks for sharing this — it's a calm, clear little puzzle, and i'd be curious how later boards feel once more is hidden. if you get a chance, i'd love you to try mine too: https://elysianx138.itch.io/dna-evolution