Finished the game! I really liked the goofy story and the Pi aspect of it. Honestly, those were what kept me going throughout the game. The platforming sometimes feels a bit unpolished, though. I occasionally fail to grab onto ledges when I expect to, and the double jump doesn't always seem to work. That said, I had a really enjoyable experience overall. With a bit more polish, I think this could be a great game. The story and quirky humor are definitely its biggest strengths for me!
Viewing post in The Tragic Life of Pi jam comments
Thank you for the feedback! I'm really happy you enjoyed the story and humour! :)
Regarding the double jump, thanks for pointing this out. A few people have mentioned similar issues now, so I suspect there's definitely something going on. Unfortunately, I haven't been able to reproduce it myself, although I think that's partly because, as the developer, I'm so familiar with how the mechanics are supposed to work that I might not notice when something feels wrong to other players.
Would you mind giving me a little more detail about when it happened? Was it in any particular location, or did it seem random?
I suspect there might be an issue with jumping from moving platforms, as I've noticed some odd behaviour there when watching other people play.
Another possibility is that the game doesn't communicate the changing abilities clearly enough. After your second main death, the double jump is replaced with the ability to slow down time, so you can no longer double jump. I wonder if that might have caused some confusion?
As for the ledge grabbing, I've noticed a few situations where the collision detection isn't quite as forgiving as it should be, particularly when the cat is slightly below the edge of a platform. I made some adjustments before release, but it sounds like there's still room for improvement!
Did you notice these issues mostly around moving platforms, or were they happening elsewhere too?
Thanks again for playing all the way through, and especially for taking the time to give such helpful feedback. It's really appreciated! :)
Well with double jump I think firstly the problem is visual because there is no effect or sound that you did a double jump and when you are in air you can't see if you jumped.
One solution might be to add a sound or visual effect when jumping. Also, if the platforms are off-screen, you could smoothly widen the camera's field of view to give the player better visibility.
Also considering double jumps yeah I had most problems with it on the platforms I press space and expect I will be able to jump to the other side then press space second time and nothing happens I just fall. The location where I failed because of this the most is probably the 3rd times moving platform appear I think where you have to cross 3 moving platforms.
About the edge grab I think you made collider to small or something like that because when you come from the UP side to the edge he grabs nicely. But the animation of the cat is she comes from a bit down so as a player I expect that I can grab even when I'm a bit down but no I just got through and died.
Hope this helps and that you fix it, would like to try updated version :)
Thank you so much for the feedback, I'll definitely consider those suggestions about sound and visual effects for the jump (I initially wanted to add a bit of pixie dust or something on the second jump to make it seem more mystical, but ran out of time).
For the problems with the double jump, I'll probably need to add some debugging, because unforuntately I still wasn't able to recreate it. :(
I did manage to recreate the ledge grabbing issue, I think he gets caught on the side of the ledge for some reason.