I'll start by saying something everyone else pointed out; the graphics are awesome! You found and held on to this specific "Binding of Isaac" artstyle and whatever game you work on, it just looks amazing.
Audio was top-notch as well, however the looping ambiences in cutscenes and in the background did cut off every now and then, and also when a new loop was coming, so that kinda ticked me off occasionally. Other than that, each piece of audio immersed me completely into your world.
The game was enjoyable and fun. Nothing felt out of place and was tied very well. It's challenging definitely, but that's part of the charm, I'd say.
The whole game felt fresh, so simple yet the experience is unique. In that sense I give it a high score in originality and innovation.
What I particularly have a problem with is the theme aspect. I personally find it wrong to connect the theme term to the lore and be done with it. This theme should play a part constantly, constantly at the back of your head, be it through audio, graphics or gameplay. What this game did was use the theme slogan to explain why the character (we) is doing something in the game, but did not connect to the experience and how it feels. I would also dare to say that the "Keep it alive" doesn't really feel connected to the son either, more like a "Keep it growing", just because it feels like the son isn't even in immediate danger.
Regarding UI/UX, I would suggest making the "being viewed" eye icon not a line, but a slightly-open eye. At first I thought it was a stamina bar, only later I found out it was actually a closed eye.
All around, an amazing and polished game. Well done! If you got time, I would also like to hear your feedback regarding our game as well. That's all!