Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+1)

It's pretty apparent to me that there was at the very least some AI assistance with the artwork, which wouldn't bother me as much if you were upfront about it. But saying "No generative AI was used" comes across as a little dishonest to me.

(4 edits)

Before you resort to judging me and calling me dishonest, please read every post and comment relating to what I created. Where in any of my posts, comments did I ever mention that no Ai was used. I was never asked the question in the first place. All my characters are hand drawn, as you will notice if you  looked at all my game's sprite sheets and my entire art portfolio in the link  on my game's page and also the video I posted today showing the process of creating my characters where I designed the Griffin from scratch to finish in under 2 hrs proves that I have the speed and capability, and anyway, the Game Jam doesn't restrict using existing UI design and Ai design for backgrounds and elements. If everyone is making such a big issue about Ai, then the video that I posted today in my 2nd Devlog update with me creating a new enemy character in the game should reassure people that my artistic skill is legitimate enough to stand by my skills. Afterall I think its the level of craftsmanship in an artists animated sprites that really sets any game apart from the rest, in other words what I'm saying is, it doesn't matter whether I used bland Menu UI's or Blank backgrounds, my animated characters that I crafted myself along with the plot of the whole story which I created with No Ai would still serve the same function and still make the game look great. I don't have to prove my capabilities  to you or anyone. I played your games, and they're great by the way. At least something good came out of this whole comment where I gave you credit despite you calling me dishonest. Have a Blessed Evening ahead.

(+1)

It quite literally says on the game page "No Generative AI was used". I am not judging you as a person, I don't know you. But you DID do something dishonest, and I don't feel it's wrong to point that out. I also never said you didn't have artistic ability; on the contrary, your original artwork is quite good! In fact, that makes it all the more disheartening to see you resort to AI, because you're a perfectly capable artist who could've brought your own personal touch to every asset in the game instead of just some. I did look at your portfolio, and again, same problem. There's both some nice original artwork AND AI generated images in the same gallery, with no distinction between them beyond the visual differences themselves (which I can only spot because I'm an artist myself; a layman would have no reason to believe everything on the site wasn't your own work). All I'm asking is that you be more transparent and forthcoming about this stuff. Like you said, your use of AI doesn't change the fact that you worked hard on your own assets, so there's no reason not to disclose that from the get-go!

Anyway, thanks for giving my games a chance, I'm glad you enjoyed them. I will once again reiterate that none of this is an indictment on your character, only a criticism of this one particular thing that bothered me a little. Judging by your willingness to separate your feelings about my comment from the games I've produced, I'd say you're a pretty swell guy. And since you're a pretty swell guy, I have faith that you'll take my words into consideration for the future. I hope you have a great night as well.

(2 edits) (+1)

You're completely right about the page tag—this is my very first time on itch.io and a game jam, and with the tight deadline I rushed through the submission setup and mistakenly selected "No Generative AI was used." I honestly didn't realize where that tag was showing until you pointed it out specifically, so thank you for bringing it up and apologizing for coming across defensively earlier.

As I mention on my portfolio, I'm an interdisciplinary artist, and I've always relied on my own hand-drawn artwork and animation to bring projects to life. When AI tools arrived, I found them useful as an additional medium to help speed up certain background and UI tasks and make the overall presentation look as vibrant and eye-catching as possible for players to enjoy.

I've just updated the project's Generative AI metadata tag on itch.io and added a clear Art & Asset Disclosure to both the AI statement and the game description so everything is 100% transparent from the get-go: all playable characters, enemies, sprite sheets, and animations are 100% hand-drawn by me, while AI tools were used for environmental backgrounds and select UI elements.

Appreciate the constructive feedback and the kind words about my original artwork. Best of luck! 🙌