33 of these 36 five-star ratings came from accounts created within the same 74-minute window. That seems a bit strange, don’t you think?

How do you explain car2305’s "Downloading for my PS now" comment when your submission only lists Windows 11? It reads like a bot confused "PSX era inspired" with an actual PlayStation release. Combined with the five-star ratings from so many newly registered accounts, that adds to the concerns about whether this feedback is authentic.
You're saying dozens of your friends all signed up and started leaving five-star ratings in rapid succession? The screenshots show 33 of 36 rating accounts registered within the same 74-minute window, with ratings coming in minute after minute. Add the "downloading for my PS" comment on a Windows game, and the whole thing still feels very off to me. I still hope your submission does well, and I wish you the best of luck with the jam.