Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Pros:

  • The art style is absolutely beautiful! I really love the overall aesthetic of the game, especially the church, lighting, shadows, and background details.
  • The atmosphere is fantastic. The combination of the visuals, sound effects, and religious horror elements creates a really immersive and unsettling environment.
  • The sound design is especially good! I love the church bells, creepy giggling, and other environmental sounds that help build tension.
  • I appreciate that new abilities and mechanics are introduced as you progress through the nights. Once I realized this was happening, the progression made a lot more sense.
  • I like the star rating system at the end of each night! It's a nice way to show how well the player performed and gives some motivation to improve.
  • I really liked the death sequence! The animation of being dragged into the floor was genuinely cool and fit the horror atmosphere perfectly.

Suggestions:

  • My biggest suggestion would be to improve how the mechanics are introduced. When I first started, I was presented with a large instruction manual containing numerous controls and explanations. It was pretty overwhelming trying to remember everything before actually playing.
  • I think a more gradual tutorial would help tremendously. For example, introducing each mechanic individually as it becomes relevant, rather than showing players eight different keybinds at the beginning.
  • I eventually realized that additional abilities unlock with each night, which is great! However, I wish this had been explained more clearly at the beginning so I didn't feel like I needed to memorize everything immediately.
  • Pressing Escape to access the book or menu was a little frustrating because it also seemed to make me exit the game. A different keybind or an on-screen button might work better.
  • The holy water UI was confusing initially. I thought the number displayed represented how much an ability cost, rather than how much holy water I currently had. Because of this, I kept using the more expensive Cleanse ability instead of regular holy water. Making the current resource amount and individual ability costs more visually distinct would help a lot.
  • I noticed that the cost of cleansing increased throughout the game. While I understand this adds difficulty, it could be explained more clearly so players can plan how to manage their resources.
  • I sometimes struggled to identify where threats were coming from. For example, I could hear giggling somewhere in the chapel, but I wasn't sure which statue or area I needed to investigate. Some additional visual or directional audio cues would help.
  • Night Two seemed to begin with a relatively high corruption level carried over from the previous night. This felt intimidating since I was already struggling to manage my resources. It might be worth considering resetting corruption or reducing it slightly between nights.
  • The nights felt a little long at times, particularly during the slower sections. I think slightly shorter early nights, with the duration increasing alongside the difficulty, could make the pacing feel better.
  • One very minor thing: I initially thought "September" referred to the month rather than the character's name! A little more context in the introduction could help establish the character and story.