Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Hey! Just created Tollmere for the fun of it. It's a cosy idle RPG with inspiration from Runescape and Melvor Idle.
Any feedback is appreciated (Even "Just delete the game bro")
https://mastertall3.itch.io/tollmere

Downloaded your game, ready to give it a try (Fair warning, horror isn't my cup of tea but I'll give it a fair review as best as I can)

(+1)

Just played your game, interesting concept to be honest. I enjoyed the writing, quite cheeky and funny.

Some of the things I would point out are:

  1. Clues not being so obvious. You already mention sparkling objects in your "Advice" texts so maybe the character dialogue could be a bit more mysterious and vague?
  2. I noticed the sofa sparkles didn't disappear after I interacted with it, not sure if this was intended
  3. The intro was very abrupt, perhaps a more softer transition to the initial text?

The rest looked good, very nice art direction and unique concept

Thanks for the feedback!

I also tried out your demo. -It’s very comprehensive, with a lot of farming mechanics. -The interface is concise. -I really enjoyed the combat—specifically the need to press a button at the right moment to deal extra damage.

There’s a banking and trading system that seems interesting, though I didn’t have time to explore it in depth.

  • I couldn’t find a general tutorial for the game—perhaps I just missed it?

  • If you’re not very experienced, it’s easy to get lost regarding what tasks to focus on.

  • Personally, I might have included fewer options at the start—such as fishing or gathering—to keep the mechanics a bit lighter for the player.

I really like the atmosphere and the simple, cozy style.

Just two quick questions about my demo:

-Where did you stop in the story?

-Did you encounter any enemies?

Thanks for the chat!

Thanks for the feedback! It really gives me another perspective on the game

You are absolutely right. I am too used to playing my own game that everything is normal and a new player can feel overwhelmed or that there is not enough guidance. I'll definitely release a new version with some changes to the start of the game.

I went back to your game today! Reached part 2. So a few things I would point out, and none of them actually related to the core gameplay, just my opinions:

  • Core gameplay looks nice, as I mentioned. However, it seems too fast and straightforward. I don't know what your target audience is but I progressed really quickly through everything. I think it goes back to my original comment on keeping things a bit more vague. But this is just my view.
  • Combat is quite unique, the card mechanism as well. Only thing I would point out is the ability to skip cutscenes at that stage but the rest is good, explanations are clear and you make it easy for the player to learn the combat

Music and sounds are spot on, really kept the tension. Although this does not seem like a hardcore horror game, it does have suspense.

Oh! Thanks—that’s a really interesting perspective, and it’s going to be a big help.

Like you, I’ve been playing through my own demo over and over, and I’m finding it hard to step back and get a fresh look at it.

I was worried it might be too difficult, but I think I’ll actually try to ramp up the challenge a bit to improve the progression.

I wasn’t quite sure—did you like being able to skip the cutscenes about game story or for combat cards, or did that feel like a drawback? You’re right, it’s not “hardcore” horror; I’m trying to build suspense—though there will be more “gore” later on—it’s more in the vein of Alone in the Dark.

The horror is more psychological—specifically regarding the highly toxic relationship between Patty and her father—and the difficult choices players will have to make, which I hope will create a sense of unease.

If you release a new version, please let me know—I’d be happy to play through it again!

(+1)

No worries! Happy to provide feedback!

I don't think it was difficult, but then again, this is my view. You'd probably need a few more people testing to get an actual feel but ultimately the game is yours so you are free to set the pace. Everyone will have a different opinion.

I enjoy the option of being able to skip the cutscenes (Even though I saw all of them). I wasn't able to skip the card cutscene though, that was what my comment was about. I got the same card twice for the Magic enemy but couldn't skip. Maybe I wasn't clear, that's my bad.

The music definitely helped build up the scene, I wouldn't change that at all. The interaction with elements also seemed smooth.

I've just released a new version of my game if you want to check it out!

(+1)

Thanks for this discussion—it’s a relief, because developing on my own without really talking to anyone about my project stresses me out a bit. I’ll definitely enjoy playing your new version!