Spoilers below, and sorry for the length. Got this as part of the Racial Justice and Equality bundle, finally played this week. Great VN, should've played earlier!
My first playthrough, I loved every moment... until the end. Jude path, except I'm 100% "open door." Wouldn't choose "closed doors" except for pure completionism. (I respect everyone else's choices, but that's mine). So I got "Shattered Ties," felt disappointed and almost left it at that. Glad I didn't.
I still wanted to know more about the characters, the setting, the lore, what even happened on the last day. Looking at the guide was a game-changer. Seeing the "bad girl" endings on the guide immediately caught my attention, so I gave the VN another shot and I was IN. From there, did the remaining 27 endings in about a week, saving Eva's (the best, imo) for last. The skip function & many save slots helped a lot!
Jude's endings: everything with Sam was very moving and tragic. My heart was absolutely breaking for her, some of the most emotional scenes of any ending. My last Jude note: did we ever get to use the knife he gave us?
Micah's endings: of these, I favored Exiled Together and Another New Start. Some closure via confronting his ex. Plus these endings are satisfyingly on the longer side, with twists and drama and several scenes before the absolute end. I like that this path gives some complexity to the non-monolithic sandmen, that's a plus for the overall story. Also: bi rep was nice to see, especially in an LI. My last Micah note: who turned him in? Or can the mayor's people just listen-in to conversations in his room?
Gloria's path and endings: she's not a good match for Ashlynn (more on that below) but she's actually the most fascinating character to me. Gloria is the only LI who was born in Camden (to an influential founding family, even), and she's never seen the surface. So, some of her personality and flaws could reflect being raised there. She keeps up appearances and seems well-liked, but actually lacks close bonds with anyone, feels judged by her family, and may be desperate for others' approval. Unlike rebels who've lived on the surface, Gloria joins the rebellion out of genuinely tragic naivete. It's like a game to her until it actually happens, and that's sad as hell. But also really interesting.
I feel for Gloria and love her chaotic energy, but can admit she's not good for Ashlynn. Their dynamic isn't exactly equal or requited, details like the one-way gift-giving at Summer's End show this. But I'm a sucker for doomed yuri, so I still appreciate how well-written Ashlynn's angst, longing, denial and heartbreak is in these Gloria endings (especially Dying Beside Her - giving everything for a woman who isn't that into you and loving her til your last breath? Devastating. Amazing. 10/10, no notes!). It's also cool to see Ashlynn in more of an active, protector role, adding another layer to her character. Brand New Camden was also a standout for me, Gloria has everything she wanted yet you can feel Ashlynn's creeping doubt under the triumphant music. Love a conflicted victory.
Eva's path and endings: I put off her path as long as possible because, due to personal experiences, cops as LIs are usually a no-go for me. Even if their character art is top tier. But seeing the guide and learning she is passionately "open doors" (a turner, you might say) led me to play with an open mind. Now she's my favorite LI, and my favorite path to replay!
Eva's path is a step up because, compared to other major characters, she has the most personal stake in the storm incident. She was assigned to the entrance that day, when people outside were banging and begging for rescue... and she was ordered not to help them. She has family on the surface. The mayor's decision may have killed her grandparents, and there were unresolved feelings between her and them. Words (and unspoken things) from the mayor and Vince in the following weeks make that pain deeper for her, which might be why we find her pommeling a punching bag in the gym or drinking herself into a stupor at Icarus. Her growing relationship with Ashlynn seems like a bright spot in an otherwise dark, isolating time for Eva. But with all that surface charm and joking around, most wouldn't know she's hurting.
One Eva moment that really tugs my heartstrings, is during the dance. She always pulls Ashlynn close and asks to hold onto this moment, because it's wonderful. She knows the rebellion is coming, that it's risky, and that something (maybe everything) will end. Her endings were also some of the most emotional for me. I like that she's always trying to protect Ashlynn from harm, whether they're ride-or-die or on opposite sides, either way she still wants Ashlynn safe. Ashlynn goes to extremes to keep Eva safe, too. New Beginnings is my favorite Eva ending, but Stepping Into the Sun has a great mix of emotions. Dying Together is so well-written and had me back in my doomed yuri feelings. I can't not sing a bit of Finneas's "Die Alone" in my head when I think of that one.
Hopefully it's obvious that I loved this game. Thank you so much for making it! Since I got it from the bundle, the two constructive criticisms I'd like to offer are about deepening diversity and racial justice. First, the game's cultural references (like Titanic, and 90s grunge) seemed majority-white to me, so there could be room to show that more BIPOC culture survived the apocalypse and impacted humanity's future. Second, the scenes with Micah getting suddenly locked up, and either Gloria or Vince going down in a hail of bullets, were a bit uncomfortable... especially for a game in this specific bundle. I can appreciate that at least they weren't the only Black characters, but the real life context still came a-knockin' when I played. Despite these criticisms, I was still blown away by the art, writing, music, and abundance of heart I found in As We Know It. Thanks again.