Hi lavexi,
Now I've played this game for more than an hour as an inquisitor, trying to go off the rails and build it as a damage character and instantly hit a wall.
The game is quite fun and hooks the player to continue to play. So this game has alot of potential with the talent system, items and the weapons. However...
1. Classes are not really customizable, even if there are talents. Cause i can't equip anything outside of the intended items. This removes any type of theorycrafting and reduces the depth of the classes, leaving them a bit of a railway.
If balance is a concern here, remember that you sacrifice character depth for balance in a RPG.
2. RPG Maker UI can hurt a bit of the immersion, i see you have removed it at some places, but i see it at other. However, i think you know of this.
3. alot of text at start, while this is an introduction, the start of the game is where you wire in your players, if this is to much, you might lose players. Sidenote: unable to skip the intro, especielly when making a second character.
4. sudden battle at empty tiles, i know RPG maker games tend to do this, be careful with it. It can become really tedious since players have an idea of what they focused on and unforeseen and unskippable battles throws that off. Like dragons in skyrim was fun at first, but after the 15th dragon, they are just annoying
5. Combat at start is a bit 1-3 abilities, but it does get better, tho i didnt see much difference in def red and boost.
6. i didnt see any items changed.
7. is it a sandbox, once i am out of the start, a player in an RPG should be able to walk where ever they like. Look at the Elder scrolls games, players always end up not going after the main quest, they run into the wild and get killed by a mud-crab
8. there's a quest helper, could be good, could not. good for tutorial quests, find a limit
Bugs found:
1. outside of the goblin hideout, if you dont move and press space, you end up talking to a non-existing goblin
2. Chess made an illegal move, they moved their knight while king was checked, causing me to be allowed to just take the king directly.
With this said, I love RPG games, MMO specifically. It was fun to try it out!
Thanks!