A lot more to a fishing pole than meets the eye... that's for sure.
As you find more fish it does progress and cause special interactions to happen. The number of new fish you find and give to her influences where she is and what she is doing as well as what you can talk to her about. But be warned, she does love to wander around if something catches her eye! The fish itself that you give her does not matter, rather, the number of fish out of five that have been caught influences progression.
Other interactions include walking away when she is giving you fun facts... she fears she may have bored you. Finding other items on the beach, like shells, allow you to give it her as well. As for the past between the player-character and Aphae; more is revealed as you make your way up towards the summit.

