Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Karni

22
Posts
1
Topics
A member registered Dec 09, 2021

Recent community posts

I took a look at this game again with someone else and we were able to interpret what you were trying to achieve. It kind of feels like a puzzle game that requires a bit of thinking. I think this would be kind of cool to actually incorporate in a bigger game as like a side quest to completing something. It's pretty cool you were able to think of something like this. Kudos to you! 

Hello everyone! Thank you so much for your patience in waiting for the results of this game jam. I appreciate everyone who signed up and also everyone who participated! It means a lot to me to know that people are still interested in making games and it gives hope to see the skill sets that you all have and the unique creativity that you bring to the table.

I'd like to start of by saying once again, this game jam was actually accidentally made. It was something made entirely within my inner circle and originally was not supposed to be extended out to the wider audience. But it seems like the passion was greater than my ability to make a private link, and I was met with a really really cool group of people. So as they say, happy mistakes!

As a result I needed to lock in and actually judge. My personal judgement criteria is as such:

1. Theme (How did you relate to the theme?) /10

2. Gameplay (What were the mechanics?) /10

3. Fun (Did I have fun playing/watching?) /10

Note: Please know that this game jam is all fun and games. There was no intent to offend anyone with my scoring. If you are unhappy, please know that you are still a wonderful person at the end of the day and that my judgement is nothing but arbitrary. Keep gaming and keep developing!

We had over 60+ participants but only 19 submissions in the end! Of those 19, 3 of them were actually from people that I know so I'm going to omit them from the judgement and hold a personal internal judgement with them. The reason being is because it's hard to discern them from the rest of the crowd and will lead to bias. So for the remaining 16 submissions, the following winners of Karni's October Game Jam is:

1. October is a Moving Day by Unrendered-Dev and CatBoxx Studios

2. Boorman by Devious Digital and Josh

3. Last Signal by Ethan Johnson

If you're curious to see how I came up with the final scores, please feel free to go through each of the submissions and check the comments section where I break down my scoring. As for the prizes, I will reach out to the winners individually. If you are one of the top winners and happen to be in this discord server, please notify me directly in the discord. I know I promised a participation prize for all participants so I will reach out to you guys individually via email to get in contact! (Some of you are on the discord already so that helps). Once again, thank you so much. It truly meant a lot to see all you actively partaking in this. I'm curious to know if you'd like to actually have some more game jams in the future. Otherwise you are free to leave the server if you'd like! As much as I'd love to keep this place open, there are minors in here and I'd like to keep a safe environment for you all.

Thank you so much for participating in this game jam! I really was excited to play your game just based on the vibes of it. I'm really curious about your team. Did you have any specific voice actors or did you guys use AI in place of that? What gave you the idea of the setting? I love that it was set in Africa. Your trailer was incredible! I wish you gave more of a description. I think if you could pull together a marketing team, this is a game you can maybe email out to youtubers and have them play it on stream and make videos to promote it! Nice job guys!

1. 10/10 I appreciate you using the fall theme starting with the idea of it being the fall of two friends.

2. 8/10 When I opened up the game to play, it was clear that this was really well made. I can see how much effort was put into this. Unfortunately I couldn't play for more than 3 minutes because the game crashed my laptop twice. Either way for what I was able to look around and check it, it was pretty cool.

3. 10/10 Despite not playing it that much, it was still extremely engaging and I already wanted to commit to learning about the story and figuring out the underlying situation that I was about to be in.

28/30

Thank you so much for participating you two! So happy to see people collaborate for this game jam. This game looked really cool when I first saw the cover image. Your demo video trailer is also really well edited, I'd love to know how you did that! I feel like this game is something you guys should perfect and maybe even share with some youtubers to play because I think this game is competitive enough where youtubers would love to play this for a video.

1. 10/10 Definitely encompasses the theme of fall with the seasonal atmosphere.

2. 9/10 Gameplay was really great! Only thing I do have to comment is that the words were going by a little too quickly so I wasn't sure what I had to do because the text was going by too fast.

3. 9/10 The game was actually really really fun. I'm really upset though the Big Chonk distracted me and all the racoons ended up getting to my pumpkins. Big sad but big fun!

29/30

Thank you so much for submitting to my game jam! I think you're one of the few people that did use Unity. Most others did in browser apps or used other simple platforms. I'm not the best at Unity but I'm surprised to see how well AI can perform in creating games so that was interesting to learn.

1. 10/10 I can see how you used to the fall of civilization as your interpretation of fall through this game.

2. 8/10 The gameplay of your game looked really sick! It's cool how you can use the mouse to aim pretty well. I wasn't able to personally open and run your game unfortunately. I was stuck with a pink screen but the video showed a lot of different scenes and also different attacks which I thought was really cool!

3. 9/10 Genuinely it looked like such a fun game. I loved that there were different scenes that changed the mood and the stress of how to complete it so I thought that was really really interesting.

27/30

Thank you again for another one of your submissions! I definitely agree with your use of AI although I encourage you to be a bit more critical with it and with your prompting. I love the idea and the vibe of the game that you're going for, but it definitely has a lot more room for improvement. I do understand we all have a limited use of credits so it can be hard to make adjustments.

1. 7/10 I can see what you mean with the idea of the theme but it is a bit of a stretch.

2. 6/10 The gameplay is a bit confusing. You start off the game and I'm not sure what I'm looking at if it's a menu or what I'm exactly doing. The words are also a bit too small to read making it harder to understand what I'm supposed to be doing.

3. 6/10 Since I'm having a hard time following along, I wasn't able to have that much fun, but I still really appreciated the visuals and the concept.

19/30

Thank you for participating in my game jam! At least you were able to create a game for this one whereas mine was not really working for yours. It's a really simple idea but very easy to execute which you did perfectly of course nonetheless. Loved the idea, it was super clever and I'm glad you got to put this together real quick! I appreciate your participation!

1. 8/10 The theme was a bit of stretch for me, although I still thought it was just to be able to create something you were interested in so I'll give you points for that.

2. 8/10 Gameplay was really smooth, but I was confused as first because I thought I could jump over everything and also I didn't know the rewards on the floor were rewards I thought they were mousetraps that I had to avoid.

3. 8/10 It was still pretty fun to play a fully functioning game! Although not sure if it tops others, it still was really cool!

24/30

Thank you so much for participating in my game jam! I'm really proud of you for making a fully fledged game and in Godot! That's very impressive. Really loved how you also were able to make stick man into something a bit more serious and emotional.

1. 10/10 I can definitely see how this game reflects fall through the fall of civilization

2. 6/10 Unfortunately the game was really laggy for me making it really difficult to play. Not sure if it was running too much or if it's faster directly in Godot. There was also some pretty entertaining bugs (like the main character walking backwards at times)

3. 7/10 Despite the lag, it still was a very enjoyable game. I appreciate you editing the video to share the different chapters. It just was a bit too long.

23/30

Thank you so much for participating in my game jam! Really proud of you for putting your first game on itch.io. It was interesting to see how you chose to create a mobile game so I'm curious to know what mobile games inspired you to create this or if this is just for your love of mobile games in general.

1. 8/10 I understand that you were relating to the theme of the fall of civilization although it was a bit difficult to see that via the game, moreso I was only able to interpret that only because you explained it.

2. 5/10 The gameplay is a bit difficult to follow along. I'm just not quite sure what I should be doing and also I wasn't really even sure which person on the screen I was so I couldn't tell if I was winning or losing.

3. 6/10 It still was really cool to see you put together a mobile game. It's pretty interesting to see how AI can interpret our current mobile games. Although it wasn't the most entertaining because I wasn't sure how to level up or what was going on, I see potential.

19/30

Thank you so much for participating! I really appreciate the time and effort you took into creating this game. I'm really curious to know what games inspired you and if you were trying to experiment with creating something new with this game.

1. 10/10 I can definitely see how you incporated the theme of fall with the fall harvest.

2. 7/10 The gameplay was definitely pretty interesting. I loved how there were a lot of different elements and things you could do. It was definitely a bit difficult to play on the computer and I could see in the video how the fighting mechanic was a bit janky (albeit it this is a short game jam so the expectations for perfection is low).

3. 7/10 The game was pretty cool to explore all of the different things that you could do. It was a bit long and I wasn't completely clear on what I should be doing at all times, but I loved the dark impending doom that I was waiting for.

24/30

Thank you so much for submitting a game that you're proud of to my game jam. I thought this was a really clever and unique game and I absolutely love reading based games with imagery attached to it to provide visuals and better imagination. I love how you came up with this idea and I'd love to know what games inspired you to create this.

1. 8/10 The fall theme is definitely there although a bit of a stretch. I think it was still very nice to see you come up with this idea to participate.

2. 6/10 The gameplay is a little tough and the reason is because it's a little too text heavy. I love reading based games but starting the game off adding 3 characters to a scene that shows no characters is a bit confusing. Who am I? What am I doing? What am I looking for? There was a lot of questions in entering the game that I think the AI overwrote the scenario for. Simplifying it would help immensely.

3. 6/10 I did really enjoy the game, although it was a bit difficult to follow along. I do love how there was a folder that was simply text based evidence which I thought was very smart and cool. However, because it was so immensely text heavy and hard to follow along, it made it a little less fun to play.

20/30

Thank you for participating, not once, but twice in my game jam! I'm glad I was able to create an environment for you to be able to test your boundaries and create some really cool games! You really do have the ability to market your games really well and I think that's a really important skill to have. You also have a really good eye for what looks good and not only that but what sounds good. These are really important elements to game design and it's how you can get an audience really engaged in what you create.

1. 10/10 You really did capture the theme by kicking people off ladders and making them fall

2. 6/10 There was a point where there was way too much movement on the screen because everytime I would kick, throw rocks, or pick up anything the screen would shake and all of the words were covering me so it got a bit hectic. If you're planning to publish it just make sure to include an epilepsy warning.

3. 8/10 It was definitely a lot of fun to play but there was a point I just didn't know when it was going to end and I couldn't even see anything because there was too much going on. Very fun though would recommend.

24/30

Thank you so much for participating in my game jam. Through this game, I feel like you really understood how to create a calming and relaxing game. I'm not sure what prompt you chose, but I feel like you have the skill set to develop a cozy game that could help be anxiety reducing and relaxing sort of like stardew valley or animal crossing. You have a lot of potential.

1. 10/10 Love your use of the theme being both the vibe of the game and literally the falling leaves.

2. 7/10 The gameplay was a little simplicistic, although I really did enjoy it. The complexity was a little limited.

3. 7/10 I had a lot of fun playing especially seeing the ending of getting the last leaf which was very cute. But I did feel it was a little boring. I think that really helped with my anxiety though haha.

24/30

Thank you so much for participating in my game jam! I really appreciate the time and effort you put into this game. Just to clarify, is the name of the AI model you used called Sloane Harrington? I wasn't sure if that's an accessible model or something you created or the name of your account or you.

1. 8/10 It was a little hard to grasp the theme of this game but I can see how you incorporated fallen leaves. The description you provided is a little confusing though.

2. 5/10 The gameplay is pretty confusing. I was trying to follow along with the video and even attempted playing the game myself but it is a very complex game making it hard to understand what I'm supposed to be doing. Whenever there's a lot of text, it's hard to know what text I should be looking to instruct me.

3. 5/10 Again since I had a hard time understanding how to play this game, it wasn't as fun, but I'd love to know more about the concept of this game to see the potential it has.

18/30

You hold a very special place in my heart for being the first person to submit a game for the first ever game jam I have held. This was a really cool game and I'm really happy that you participated (not once, but twice!). I'm really curious why you picked the title that you did for this game.

1. 10/10 Fall of civilization makes sense and it's cool you interpreted it as such!

2. 8/10 I was struggling a bit trying to infect other creatures because I think the speed was the exact same as mine, but it still was pretty cool nonetheless. There were a few bugs I spotted that were spinning and stuck (of course this is a month long game jam and I'm not expecting a perfect game).

3. 7/10 The game was definitely fun, but I'm unsure what my goal was and how it would have ended. Like agar.io, you were trying to infect everyone and be the last one standing which is what I assumed for this game but it was hard to know how many were left.

25/30

Thank you so much for participating Sal! I really appreciate you so much. You're actually kinda goated with the sauce. 

1. 10/10 Very creative use of the theme. I like how yours was different! You used the theme as a word and I thought that was very clever.

2. 9/10 This is such a unique game. I'm so impressed by the use of AI. I was testing it out and I feel like there could be half points for synonyms. For example I was trying to guess carro but the right word was coche. But this helps with anxiety if you're going somewhere you don't know and you want to be able to explain something for a place in the world in the language that they speak.

3. 8/10 It was definitely a lot of fun! I think I would enjoy this game if it was competitive against friends where we would all be put in the same place and try to guess any many words as possible.

27/30

Thank you so much for participating in my game jam! I'm really impressed with what you were able to create using AI. I'm really curious what prompt you used and what tools you used to create this. I love how it started with a comic strip to give a story and then lead directly into the game. The video you provided showed all the scenes, which I appreciated. The monsters were really unique looking and the fighting style was pretty sick!

1. 10/10 I can see how you related to the theme with the fall of civilization through a zombie apocalypse. I would have liked if you could explained this a little bit so that I could understand how it related.

2. 7/10 The gameplay was a little tough. I had to jump over barriers and I almost always got hurt because I couldn't attack the zombies, I would have to jump over them but I always got caught. There was also a bit of lag when I was near death so just a few bugs (which is a given this is a sort game jam)

3. 8/10 It was definitely fun to play! I loved the music and the vibes, but it was a bit difficult to play which is why I'm not giving a full score.

25/30

Thank you for actually participating in my game jam Manny. The idea was to get my friends to participate, and you were one of the 3 and that means a lot to me. I haven't heard your voice in such a long time so it took me back to our VGDC days hearing your voice on the video. I really loved how you started the game with this story of a frog that couldn't jump because he was in a wheelchair and then you were able to lead into a really good game based on that simple story. This is exactly what the point of my game jam was for. Just a short simple demo and showcasing your capabilities. Really proud of you for utilizing your resources and skills to put this together.

1. 10/10 I can totally see how you related to the theme which you went with a more literal approach. Nice!

2. 8/10 Gameplay was a little tough but the fact that you picked something pretty difficult to recreate is really impressive.

3. 8/10 It was really fun but definitely I did get pissed so it did work!

26/30

Thank you for participating in my game jam. I appreciate that you submitted something even thought you didn't submit anything directly. But, I searched on your itch.io page and found the game so I was able to download it and play it! I really loved that you hand drew most of the assets (the lady bug is suspiciously drawn well). It was actually a very entertaining game and I was actually struggling. Unfortunately due to the lack of my gaming skills, I was unable to win this game, which you were correct. This is indeed a hard game.

1. 5/10 Didn't really relate to the theme but I can sort of see the vision? If the tree gets hurt then it falls, which is what I want to assume what you meant in relation to this theme.

2. 7/10 Gameplay was pretty straight forward. I saw you included a very brief instruction which I was actually able to follow along with.

3. 8/10 It was definitely fun to play!

20/30

It has been done! https://discord.gg/VzUPtGZ45

You know based on the number of people who have joined, it seems like I'll have to make a discord so stay tuned I'll keep you all updated!

You can have multiple submissions if you'd like! You have the rest of October to make a game and I don't want you limit you!