Thanks for a very detailed question!
The original idea was to play by the guest quota and to not decrease the popularity. Allowing the guest number to stay the same would pretty much make each year a shop drafting attempt, there you play more or less the same layout and search for the best tile to add. And forcing the player into increasing the guest count in each subsequent year would force the game to add at least one guest building into the shop and forcing the player to buy it. The popularity quota was also possible, but it would pretty much make all the shop prices irrelevant, as you would get more and more popularity each year. So I decided to go the "tax" route. I do agree it's not the most pleasant way for the player, but gameplaywise it made for the best dynamics in my opinion. I could have framed the tax as a quota, but I though it would be more difficult to explain in comparison to "you are -15, it's bad".


