Hello! Hope you're doing well!
Just finished playing the game. Conceptually, I really liked the idea. However, I felt that there were quite a few glitches and an insufficient level of polish for a paid game! (NOT ASKING FOR A REFUND BY THE WAY - Y'ALL DESERVE TO MAKE SOME CASH)
Glitches / Errors
1. My friend who used a Windows laptop with a Intel R UHD graphics 620 graphics card and played the Eli (2026) section had severe visual glitches in his playthrough: the walls of interactable houses like grandfather's house did not render when looking up, interactable objects like the noticeboards simply did not appear etc'
2. The minimap (M) / object descriptions (E) / the radio (T) overlays continued to show on screen during the chapter title transitions. So even though I was supposed to be reading about how my actions impacted the world, I was distracted by the existing screens. Did not feel polished!
3. During the first chapter, I chose to have Mara warn Walter instead of take the oil and light the lamps at the lighthouse. However, the minimap continued to show a star marker over the oil box anyway!
Typos
1. The writing was sometimes hard to understand. The grammar of the hints in the first chapter was a bit confusing.
Suggestions
1. It might be helpful if the beginning of the game introduced us to the controls + premise with more hand-holding. For example, why is Mara suddenly planting a tree? What if she had some dialogue with Eli where he asks her to prove that she's really from the past - and in response, she says that she'll plant a sapling to change the future.
2. The controls should be introduced in the game proper instead of the README file or the settings menu. There were many important controls that were never even hinted at, such as the minimap (M), sprinting (LEFTSHIFT), and jumping (SPACE).
3. The Morse code communication bit was somewhat difficult to use - would it be possible to have another key (say H or space) be used to indicate spaces between letters instead of pause time?
4. Related to above, the Morse code gimmick felt kind of pointless. There was no real reason to use it over simply sending messages. I do like the level of immersion it tried to bring, but the game's other systems simply broke that immersion. For example, at the end of the game, Eli literally tells Mara the frequency to tune the radio to... even though the radio isn't supposed to be working properly until it's tuned? One suggestion I have is to make the messaging system tied to the radio strength: when the signal is strong, Mara and Eli can text / use voice chat. When the signal is weak, they can only use Morse code.
5. Dialogue sections felt a bit strange. When talking to Walter, we got prose sections describing the conversation. Having a proper dialogue system (at least on Mara's side) would make the game feel much more alive!
6. On a similar note, more opportunities to interact with the townsfolk would be very nice! Perhaps some short dialogue with the unnamed NPCs like the guy carrying the crate or the little boy by the anchor monument who stole the winch handle and doomed the townfolk to drowning??
7. The fishing minigame by the quay was cute, but it took a bit long.
8. On Eli's side, the map was a bit drab and there wasn't much to see. My friend felt like he was just blindly following the markers on the minimap instead of exploring and enjoying the town. Would it be possible for Mara's actions to incrementally change the town by bringing back some townsfolk or fixing damaged buildings?
Overall, I think this game is quite a nice idea and has good potential! But it just lacks the level of finish I'd expect from a full game. I look forward to seeing what y'all can create in the future with more updates!
