Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

thekoalakoa

2
Posts
A member registered 21 days ago

Recent community posts

Look not trying to start a flame war. We really appreciate you adding the license.

Just one correction on section 6. The "deliver on request" route is 6(b), and it only applies when the program is shipped on a physical product. For downloads like itch, section 6(d) applies: the source has to be available from the same place as the builds, to anyone who downloads them, at no extra charge. So the easiest fix is to put a source zip or a repo link next to the builds on the itch page to comply with GPL. That's all I was asking for.

On whether the code is derived: thanks for confirming the asset extraction tool comes from our project. That alone means the GPL applies. For the rest, what caught my eye was the Boom Box VU row clock. It's our own fix, not original cart behavior, as we already have the correct cart behavior for this. Your builds match ours exactly as it was taken from Pezz who's port is based on ours: the 1001257 constant with its /100000 carry, 26 voices, the 0xE0 at 0x1B98, and the 0xFA tempo check with &0x0F defaulting to 8. The 0x88 handler's 0x80 fill over 0x1802–0x19FF matches too. If you wrote those independently and somehow came to the same patch, no problem. Once the source is up, I'm happy to compare and drop it if I'm wrong.

On WaterMelon, 100% get why people are angry they have every right to be myself included. its why Pezz, hpman project little man and us have been working so hard for the last several years on this. My worry is just practical, shipping the decompiled game publicly gives them a reason to go after every Paprium project, including the ones that only run on a cart people own. That's all I meant.

Really cool to see Paprium running on PC and N64, and decent token use on the decomp! I'm Koala from the paprium-pocket / Paprium_MiSTer team, the GPLv3 projects your code uses.

Looking through the builds, it looks like a lot of our code made it in, specifically the Boom Box VU bar row clock and the 0x88 DAC buffer fill and fixes. Since that code is GPLv3, the builds need to ship with the GPL license, a credit to the projects, and the source code immediately (not later). Totally get wanting to polish it first but its the rules & laws of open source licenses. Not to mention Krikzz Mega-ppm which is a different license completely.

I'd also kindly ask you to take down the decompiled game itself or have some sort of way for people to load their own rom. Publicly distributing WaterMelon's code puts a spotlight on the whole Paprium scene, and if WaterMelon pushes back, it could hit other preservation projects too, ours included. We'd really like to keep things calm for everyone working on this. As we have communicated with them in the past and are keeping the peace with how we are handling things.

Feel free to message me if you'd like to talk it over. Thanks for hearing me out!