First of all - I would like to preface this feedback by stating that I am a very big fan of most things mystery/murder mystery/detective stuff. Games, books, movies, you name it. So I am rather passionate about the genre. And it pains me to see this attempt at the genre, especially with the “generator” in the title. I will try to explain.
“A murder mystery generator”. Let’s decompose this, because the title itself makes me EXTREMELY skeptical of the game as a whole.
First up is “Murder”, aka “solve the murder”. Or maybe commit one.
Let’s start with the easy part, the “let’s kill some dude and get away with it”. There are plenty of games that let you do that, so the idea is not novel. See Dishonored or Hitman series. This requires you to have a very competent level design. You can’t let the player find one single way to kill everyone without getting caught - this will break the game and won’t be very fun. Because of this - first of all - you need to switch locations (or force the player to change the location of his next murder), so that the player spends some time exploring, learning his targets behaviour and planning the assasination. Skyrim is not a good assisination simulation - not only does it not have the level design needed for a good assasination - the AI has to be scripted to behave semi-believable during Dark Brotherhood missions. Otherwise - there’s gonna be a moment when a guard with an arrow through his skull peacefully greets you while you’re readying a second arrow.
If you are trying to solve the murder - it’s basically a puzzle where you have to reconstruct the events that lead to murder. Find puzzle pieces (clues/evidence) and assemble them in a finished picture. Sometimes literally - see Danganronpa or Rain Code games. Puzzle needs to be solvable - so you need to give the player enough clues so that the final picture becomes clear, otherwise it’s just not gonna be fun. You don’t want to try a murder with no clues - that’s not fun. Danganronpa dealth with this problem by having clues appear in testimonies during the trial, same with Ace Attorney games. In fact - Ace Attorney games are built around trying to find inconsitencies in testimonies, while in Danganronpa most cases could be solved by yourself, with only a handful being “what’s going on here?”, adding to the tension. Note that in every single detective/murder solving game almost every single murder happened in a different location under different circumstances - this keeps the player on the toes.
You could simplify the murder investigation to pure human interactions. If you were to consider Werewolf/Mafia board games as murder mystery games - then usually the murders can be solved by pure observation of human behaviour. Why was Player X killed on Day 3? Was he close to figuring out the killers? Did he say something important last turn? Or could he be the killer all along and took the bullet to clear suspicions from those he allied with? This would require a lot of writing, if you were to try and adapt those games to a singleplayer experience. Ace Attorney games could be considered overyly simplified version of those games.
So if you want your player to solve a murder - you either give him a puzzling situation, or a good plot that he can desconstruct himself.
And this leads us to Mystery part. The murder is a mystery until it’s solved.
The whole “mystery” part requires you to make the player interested in the mystery itself. Maybe the murder situation is insane (pretty much the entirety of Zero Escape series), or it slowly ramps up with some weird overall shenanigans going on (Rain Code). The reason you’re trying to solve the mystery is to try and understand how it happened. It seems like magic from the outside, or like a supernatural occurence, and maybe it is - you just don’t know, but you want to have a reasonable enough explanation for whatever is going on. And that explanation better be good, otherwise you will feel like you have wasted your time. This “mystery” part should basically establish the finale, the grand reveal, the plot twist (even if it’s just for a single case). See LA Noire - every case tells a little story. Very ground to earth story, but a story nonetheless. All events should lead to conclusion of this story, otherwise you’re just engaging in torture porn. Which is… fine, if you’re into that, but don’t go and call that a “mystery”. Saw movies are not mysteries, they are slasher flicks, and murderers with a motive are more fun to catch than a “I just wanna see the world burn” “My name is not important” type characters.
And then there’s the “GENERATOR”. Which implies that the game creates a murder mystery for you to solve. Or to commit your own murder. For that, in my opinion, you need: 1) For comitting murders: EITHER a) Great map design & good AI (if you’re going for a single map) b) Strong map pieces for a map randomizer + AI that can handle the generated map 2) For solving murders: EITHER
a) An large amount of pre-designed murders where you could drag&drop your characters
b) An insanely good AI that can generate a murder based on some environment
3) For “Mystery” part: EITHER a) Good story writing
b) Good character writing
In my opinion - this is a AAA kind of game. With insane amount of effort going in and a large team designing, implementing and testing the game and various outcomes. If there was such a game and it was good - I would’ve been all over that game like a fat hairy fly on a hot steaming pile of shit.
Guess it’s time to talk about your game.
I would call your game a danganronpa ripoff, because that seems to be your canvas. 15 people locked somewhere, there’s some sort of seemingly weird overseer, a trial… Okay, I don’t mind a dangan-like. But that’s where the “don’t mind” part ends.
It feels to me like you’re trying to throw as much shit as possible at the wall and see what sticks. Or maybe the smudges will hide the fact that the game fails to accomlish what it sets out to do. “Wowzers, go and peek under girls skirt! Such an ecchi idea, gosh, you’re such a coomer hehe”. Did that fail? How about “Okay, look at how many mechanics we’ve got! The girls menstruate! Uh-oh, do you wanna be stinky-dinky or will you risk committing neck rope in the bath tub? By the way, there are also ALL THESE MECHANICS LOOK AT ALL OF THEM”.
There was a game where you had to juggle a lot of mechanics, “Pathologic”. It’s not a fun game. It’s a very stressful game. And it’s also a murder mystery, believe it or not. I’d even say it’s the opposite of fun - but that was its appeal. You’re trying to power through the misery of everyone, trying to save as many people as you can while debating if its moral for you as a player to exchange syringes for pills with a local furry child. You had to keep in mind the state of close to a dozen characters while running around the city, without knowing if what you’re doing is correct or not. “Pathologic” is a good game, but it works because of the writing and the tone. You have don’t have that. You have a menstruation tutorial.
Monokuma wasn’t introduced as an evil “haha imma getcha” character. He was annoying and he was outlandish, but he was supposed to be neutral. An overseer. He wasn’t in your face - in fact, he seemed annoyed when he was in your face (it kinda changed in DR2 and DRv3, but whatever). You seem to be incapable of writing such a character - your Beatrice (or whatever the pink little girl name is from the first scene is) taunts you, dumps a tutorial on you and also acts as your sockpuppet promising me the best game ever made, just PRETEND and IMAGINE. And also please buy a bridge while you’re enjoying the spinning apple perfect game in your head. Look, I know I’m being harsh here, but there’s this “show, don’t tell” principle, and while I understand the amateurish mistake of dumping expository dialog on the player - I absolutely hate being told about what the game “will be”. The player will be the judge what the game will be, once it arrives. Before that - you’re trying to sell be a some snake oil, and I aint buing that.
Okay, you have life sim elements. Cool. I wouldn’t mind checking that out. Sure, I don’t hate the idea. Oh wait, I can’t - I need to experience GAMEPLAY before that. I need to go through the trial of ${characters.get(Random.nextInt(0, 16))} doing ${character.getDecision(Random.nextInt(0, 2))} in the team of the ${player.getCharacter()} and ${character} vs ${characters.get(Random.nextInt(0, 16))} and ${characters.get(Random.nextInt(0, 16))}. Do you see the problem? It’s soulless. Those are just templates where you insert random string. Characters don’t say anything meaningfull after the trial, its just random exclamations “How could you do this to me?”, “I knew I couldn’t trust you”, “Never should have come here” and “Stop right there, criminal scum”. There is zero personality there, just generic anime 3d models executing a single “fetch random string from a certain pool of responses”. Oblivion did that. Oblivion also had life sim elements for its NPCs. Oblivion also had a very heavily scripted murder mystery quest that is fondly remembered to this very day. It kinda falls apart if you know how Oblivion NPC scripting works, but it’s still very engaging with many different outcomes.
And then there’s the, uhh, the cooking show? That was the third strike for me. Writing is not good, and the tone falls flat. Danganronpa “TV Series” plot twist happened at the end of the game - it wasn’t staring in your face in the first 20 minutes of the game. The tone is dead. It was dead when the overseer told me to look under skirts, and the cooking show was a curb stomp on an already cold body, American History X style.
You NEED to have good, engaging writing for this kind of game, and you need EXPONENTIALLY more if you want to have a GENERATOR for those kinds of game. And even then - you risk the player remembering and recognizing the parts used to assemble the story. I haven’t experienced your level design aside from the first room (it was fine), but I grew absolutely sick of the text you were dumping on me. It wasn’t good text. Not even in the tutorials.
The sole reason I’m writing this huge wall of text is that this is not the first time you’ve done this. I will quote myself from one year ago, 06.03.2024 to be precise: /post/9503395
>It feels like you want to tell some big, interesting story, but I just can't get into it. Too many new characters and events introduced in a short time span. Anime type exposition dialogue for the orphan backstory. Giant lore dump immediately after starting the robot route. I don't mind reading, but there are also problems with writing in my opinion. You’ve had this problem before, but now it seems like it became worse. Or you decided to showcase the worst part of it first
I understand that it’s an alpha, I understand that it’s incomplete, it’s an alpha, it’s a demo, it’s a work in progress, whatever - but I don’t see any way this game could reach any amount of success. The ingridients are bad and the recipe was discarded into the trash bin somewhere at the very beginning of the development.
You don’t need life sim elements for this kind of game. Danganronpa is a fucking visual novel, so is Ace Attorney. Zero Escape games are Nancy Drew like point and click games mixed with - you guessed it - visual novel. LA Noire is not a visual novel and it was in development hell for many years. Presenting your murder mystery game without the murder mystery, but with “the characters can eat and menstruate” is like presenting an FPS game without the shooting, but with a working dialogue system with trees and character affinities. It feels like you’ve missed the point.
I have no idea who is supposed to be target audience. Coomers? Coomers have that one game from honey select devs with anime high school girls. Weebs? I don’t think weebs will appreciate some generic anime models with cardboard cutouts for characters - and weebs love cardboard cutouts characters. Murder Mystery fans? Goto line 1 of this feedback and read again.
In my opinion - this game is dead on arrival. Design was fucked from the ground up, and you’re vastly overestimating your abilities. Running “pick your favourite character” polls feels… Do you know what a “cargo cult” is? It feels like that. Like you’ve seen more successful games have huge fanbases arguing over which girl is the best, so you’re jumping straight to that part while skipping designing, writing, or making a good game.
And yes, I know this is an alpha and you’re still trying to figure stuff out. All of us are. That’s how life is - you spend it trying to learn stuff, become better, yadda yadda yadda. Nobody’s perfect. I understand.
But you don’t go deadlifting 300lbs after spending the last 15 years having a healthy bulking diet of nothing but Pizza Hut and Pepsi Zero.