This is a lot to read through, and I'll read everything carefully multiple times. So thank you for that. It's going to take a bit to reply to this.
I put "generator" in the title since it's planned to be dynamic and it's marketable. Nothing really beyond that.
It is extremely early on, most of the writing aspects aren't even started yet, and I do understand the shitty intro made in 30 minutes had too much text. I asked for the character designs since I wanted to get certain things done with before doing the major parts. Since a character's design should be close to what the personality is, it should show who they are with what they wear on the outside to others. And a bad looking game can kill a game before anything else, since this game will take a lot of time and effort, I wanted to get the graphics looking decent enough compared to my past games.
Right now the AI can only move around, not interact with anything. The player can murder using the crafting system to gather items to turn into traps and weapons to impact behaviors. So for example, an AI or the player would clog another character's toilet to force them in a public bathroom, where they can trap the door for a swinging blade trap which can kill them if the blade hits them when they go to the public bathroom. They can notice if they eat more often at breakfast or have a weird animation when are locked in the influence game that they are going to go to the bathroom eventually. The reason I had a bunch of filler text was to explain parts of the game's vision, since most people wouldn't know about things like the crafting system unless they went to the second floor into the crafting room to try it without any items gotten with the inventory system.
The main scope of the game is hanging out with everybody, character perspectives change depending on actions during the influence game. This leads to a murder/suicide. It's announced on the screen. The player can see where they have died and checked the body and other aspects of the room for evidence. Right now most of the evidence that can be gathered is in the dorm rooms (the storage box was a little bugged when you streamed, since it showed you choices in the box when there was nothing in it), and checking the bodies for how it looks like they died. There is also some smaller things like being able to smell smells from doors if acid was used or if a bathtub (placeholder model currently) has been used to clean a weapon. If someone who isn't the player is injured, there is a text box showing so. [Everything beyond this point hasn't been added yet due to the trials being one of the last things I will add.] The trials will have options to bring things up to raise suspicion on others. So if someone used the furnace to burn a weapon, they can be called out if they haven't cleaned themselves. Or if someone wrote something in a diary, it can be brought up and used as evidence. If someone uses a Medical Bed to quickly recover from an injury, it can be gathered and used against them. If someone dies from the top floor, the person who does it gets screws. Or someone who messes with medical bottles for painkillers has medical labels they have to do something with. Cross has the ability to turn normal weapon into bloody ones to falsify evidence (the player can do this if he chooses to be Cross). Which will allow for more thinking involved. Let's say Agatha was killed by a whip. Her wounds would showcase her being killed by a whip. But a bloody knife was found. The player can determine that the bloody knife wasn't used, and that someone was trying to frame someone else. But if someone beforehand died due to a knife, it can lead to questioning of "did we get the last murderer correct?". Since the player can choose a wrong answer and be punished for it. The player could also do this to get away with murder. That's the idea of the puzzle elements I want to add to the game instead of it being generic. "I killed someone in a fight, so the weapon I used doesn't matter." The player will be able to see facial reactions during trials to see how they feel, and if they should be pressed forward or not.
In the combat right now for the player, what weapons the player uses on someone is used to determine what wounds they have. If they were poisoned, the skin would have a different coloring. If punched, lots of bruises. If stabbed, stab wounds. Etc.
I fully know I need to work on my writing, and many parts of the game was quickly written so it was playable on demo day. I plan to spend a lot of time making sure it's good. Your input is very helpful for this with what needs to be done. Many of the dialogue for the influence game was made to be generic so it could be done for demo day. It needs a lot more responses for each character and unique ones, since right now everybody shares the same base of responses to choose from. But the code behind it is very sophisticated with using 60+ functions to gather viewpoints on the other team for the AI, determining views and a choice, and reacting to it. Still a little buggy, but it's mostly working as intended background wise.
I didn't want to hide the twist it's a TV show. Since I didn't want it to be a twist. More of ideas of "who is watching and who funded this and why are we all selected for this" instead of "what is the most generic thing to hide away from the player?" I personally don't like the idea of hiding it's a TV show, since I would rather have different things that are more interesting take center stage, and having people think "oh this is just another TV show twist instead of anything unique" is not a good thing. So ripping the band-aid off for that idea is better than letting the player think lesser due to that reason.
I'm adding life sim elements to fuel different ways for murders to happen, and to individually know each cast member one on one depending on who the player chose. If the player chose Edgar, it changes how people view you due to how you look. The influence game isn't completely random. It takes the default viewpoints everybody has of each other for trust, and uses that to determine if collaborating or sabotaging. Then depending on the outcome, it changes character perspective. Someone who is sabotages learns to have less trust with others. While collaborating builds trust. The gifting system already in the game develops or removes trust based on what items the player gives to someone else. Every character has a unique inventory and they will react different depending on what they have.
I fully understand the writing is the main thing holding this idea together, and I do know this will take a long time to get everything right. I knew that when I started and I have been actively trying to improve on my writing since Whiteout Frontier last year. It's my top priority to get it right with the finished game. Since this is an alpha, I quickly did what I could to get it up and running to get feedback, which has been very helpful. But I do fully understand how impactful good and bad writing is to the player. I understand what I need to do from the feedback I've gotten so far to see where it goes. All of the text in the game is probably going to be written and refined multiple times over the next couple of months.
Also, even with everything, this game isn't as complicated coding wise compared to Whiteout Frontier for the AI. The AI in that game was based around teams instead of individuals to influence how enemy teams behave when the player does any interactions. So it takes time, but isn't that hard to code. The writing is the bigger thing to get right and will take more effort.