Really liked the visuals on this one - reminded me of SNES retro graphics like Link to the Past. The game loop was fun too; it wasn't too difficult to deduce who were the suspects, but the difficulty did progress as the days went on. The story was cute too, and the sfx of the different characters was funny. If I had to critique, the HUD’s minimal aesthetic felt out of place against the retro visuals. Also maybe some higher res art for the profile pics would've been nice; for instance, the genie stood out with his high res art compared to the other characters. But other than that, great job on your first published game and first game jam! Hope to see more of your work in the future :)
Edit: the term for the mismatch pixel art is mixels (learned that from another comment!)