Nice game. Liked the visuals :)
Play game
Meemaw Manor's itch.io pageResults
| Criteria | Rank | Score* | Raw Score |
| Gameplay | #54 | 3.395 | 3.545 |
| Limitation | #71 | 3.395 | 3.545 |
| Polish | #93 | 3.133 | 3.273 |
| Overall | #100 | 3.206 | 3.348 |
| Art | #110 | 3.482 | 3.636 |
| Audio | #120 | 2.872 | 3.000 |
| Theme | #140 | 2.959 | 3.091 |
Ranked from 12 ratings. Score is adjusted from raw score by the median number of ratings per game in the jam.
Comments
Game froze here for me after i got all the chickens, ig its the bug u mentioned in the itch page. Still, Its a good game!The story and dialog for the characters had a lot of passion, the art (great for your first time with pixel art) and buggyness of the game could use some work but that kinda stuff happens, keep at it!
I will start with the minor issue I got with your game: The music wasnāt looping properly, such a shame! š« On the other hand, I Really enjoyed the writing of the little ghosts, and it shows that this story was meaningful for you, Iām happy I got to read it! I enjoyed searching for all the cake ingredients, and slicing the story into bits you get when giving each of them to ghost grandma was a good call! I also liked how at the end the cake wasnāt presented as a āmagic solutionā to real deep problemes, while still being something that brings people together. For me this kind of honest happy endings are way more satisfying than the āmagically erase every problemsā ones. Not only because to me it is more respectful to the story I spent time to get involved with, but also because i like the optimistic message it gives. Things in real life are never magicaly repeared as good as new, so a story that shows that as the happy ending gives me no hope. But the one telling me āSometime things suck, but you can still find paths that will bring you happinessā, this one gives me hope.
ANYWAY, long story short, I liked the way you takled that! GG!
Oops, sorry about the looping! I left the audio until too close to the deadline and it definitely shows
I'm glad you enjoyed the ending. The dessert might not be magic, but it is meant to be shared with the people we love. To be totally honest I was worried it might be too devastating to be considered a happy ending - but it felt like the right one
Thanks for playing!
Good writing! I had fun right up until I softlocked when trying to gather eggs; it seems likely I hit the dialogue bug you'd called out on the page. The art had a nice aesthetic to it, and I may come back to try finishing it up after checking out more games.
Funny game. I saw a comment saying the outside is a bit messy, and I agree, but I also saw you say it's your first time doing pixel art, so this is beautifully done! I love the characters too!
Haha, well it's not the literal first time I've done pixels, but it's true I don't have a lot of projects in that style. The exteriors are really bad though, and the worst part is that I knew they were and went with it anyway.
I probably should have sourced some free tiles especially where I was struggling, but I guess I wanted the game to be me as much as possible, warts and all.
Thanks for playing!
Wow this was such a touching story I really enjoyed it! The talking animations and different facial expressions add greatly to the dialog and the writing is excellent! All the ghosts are such fun characters! Big fan of the chicken guy and the poultry-geists. There are some things throughout the world that I noticed were missing collisions or the collision shape was off so you could clip over it a bit. Also there are no wall collisions in the butter ghost room! Maybe this is just a me thing, but I spent way too long looking for the locked box cause I didnāt see it on the table for the longest time (maybe a bit of highlighting or something to draw your eye to it could be nice). And lastly when you reach the end and go back to the menu and try to play again, it just plays the ending scene again. But wowie!- overall, amazing storytelling, great work! Thank you woke grandma for the cookies and pie. :D
Thanks for your kind words and playing my game!
Highlighting the items you can pick up is a really good note, and a tough nut to crack. On the one hand I don't want people to be frustrated that they can't find what they need, on the other hand I don't want it to be too-too obvious either. If I had more time for it, I think a hint mode or highlight vision toggle would be a happy compromise.
The game reloading to the ending is a definite oversight. I guess I didn't test it because I hadn't considered someone would want to play my game again :)
I guess the butter room is just so buttery that you can slip through the walls. I suppose a ghost wouldn't need that, but for us mere mortals being able to noclip through walls makes you more likely to make it in time for the first slice of Meemaw's pie
Lovely story and great writing. I enjoyed chasing down those ghost chickens and helping everyone out.
It was difficult to hear the audio, I had to restart the game and make the music a little quieter to hear it.
Otherwise, lovely work!
Oh man, I honestly ended up liking it more than I thought I would. The story was honestly so so sweet, and I wonder there's any reason why there's so many ghosts around the house?! It kinda made me wonder if there was any reason to it. The peanut themed artstyle is very cute too, the main character is cute and I loved the struggle that both the main character and the grandma went through. The limitation was also implemented decently. I think my only issue would be with the audio, having one soundtrack repeat through both silly and emotional moments kinda dumbed it down. otherwise, pretty solid!!
I had wanted to expand some more on the ghosts' backstory and their relation to Meemaw, but I had to abandon that plot for time constraints. My head canon is that they're other lost souls who think Meemaw is neat and decided to hang around.
I'd like to say those time constraints are to blame for the lackluster soundtrack... but I'm extremely guilty of leaving the sound to the end, or as an afterthought in general. Audio is definitely my weakest area
Thanks for playing!


Leave a comment
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.