Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+1)(-1)

I understand why this feels demotivating, especially for those who hand-code everything. That's a real craft and it deserves recognition. I just see it from another angle.

I was on Mega Drive because it's easier, even though I love the SNES more. I never made anything for the SNES because I was afraid it would end up being something embarrassing, a game that looked like it belonged to an older console generation. The barrier felt impossible: heavy testing, a slow CPU, a tricky toolchain. AI is what's letting me build my own tools to get past it. And it doesn't make the game for you: you still have to design it, test it a lot and deal with every SNES limitation.

I'm nobody, and maybe my game isn't any good. But I had never seen a pseudo-3D cycling race game, and I wanted to find out if it could be done, even halfway decently. That's exactly the kind of experiment AI made possible for me.

We're regular people, not studios, and a jam only gives us a few months. I always thought a jam was about trying crazy ideas within a limited time, not about entering games people have been working on for years. Honestly, that feels even less fair to me than using AI.

AI use can't really be verified, so a ban would just mean people stop declaring it, or that far fewer people enter. The disclosure field is a much fairer approach.

What I'd suggest for next year is a separate ranking or award for entries made without AI. That way hand-made work gets the recognition it deserves, and everyone else can still experiment freely.

I see this as a big opportunity for new ideas on the SNES. And if someone's game gets attention, I'm sure they'll put in the effort to improve its pixel art, music and polish. In the end, we all want the same thing: more and better SNES games.

(1 edit) (+1)(-1)

Thank you for sharing your perspective, Frosties! It's an interesting situation and I'm not really sure what the right solution is.

"In the end, we all want the same thing: more and better SNES games."

I disagree here, actually! I think there are a wide variety of reasons that people might join the jam and that this is just one of them. There's been some good discussion (and some not so good name-calling haha) on the Discord related to this same point.

For me personally, I've always been intrinsically motivated to understand my code and the system it's running on. This worked well for me because, historically, having that understanding and mastery of a system was complementary (or required!) to pursuing the extrinsic motivation of impressing others by tackling the difficult task of creating a SNES game. Two birds with one stone.

With AI, however, understanding is becoming more and more orthogonal to getting things done. You no longer need understanding or mastery to create.

A lot of the gen-AI games submitted this year are quite impressive! Or, at least, they are impressive by the pre-AI standards of what made a SNES game impressive. Maybe we have to update our standards now, but then that also feels like it moves the bar for people who choose not to use AI. I know that my non-AI game looks a lot less impressive than most of the AI games in this jam (and most of the non-AI games 😅). I still got a lot of enjoyment from pursuing my intrinsic motivation, but I would be lying if I said it didn't sting a bit to see the AI competition. Maybe that's my own fault for caring about the extrinsic motivation.

I think it's also worth mentioning that understanding and mastery are just one portion of a game jam. The games also have to be fun and unique! AI isn't great at that yet, so it does feel like games are on a more level playing field in that regard.

For me, I think it would be nice to continue having a jam where understanding and mastery are a primary goal. Maybe that's this jam, maybe that's some other jam. Maybe AI will become so ubiquitous in software dev that in a couple years this'll all be a moot point 😅

I did want to push back a little on your comment around people submitting games they've been working on for years. That's not allowed in this jam. Or maybe I'm misunderstanding your comment? Apologies if so!

I definitely don't mean to single you out with this reply! I think Super Tourmalet is a cool idea and looks quite nice :) And I'm also glad you enjoyed the jam! I did as well :D

(1 edit) (+1)(-1)

"I was on Mega Drive because it's easier, even though I love the SNES more. I never made anything for the SNES because I was afraid it would end up being something embarrassing, a game that looked like it belonged to an older console generation."

Yeah, that's the problem. Instead of accepting where you are and embracing learning and personal growth, you let your fear of shame and embarrassment push you into taking a shortcut. If you had embraced your limitations and thought creatively, you could've come up with something fresh and new.  

The barrier felt impossible: heavy testing, a slow CPU, a tricky toolchain. AI is what's letting me build my own tools to get past it. And it doesn't make the game for you: you still have to design it, test it a lot and deal with every SNES limitation.

Overcoming the seemingly impossible is what makes life exciting. No risk, no reward. Game jams are cool because people push the limits of their own abilities to get things done in a limited amount of time. Without that, why even have a time limit at all?

I'm nobody, and maybe my game isn't any good. But I had never seen a pseudo-3D cycling race game, and I wanted to find out if it could be done, even halfway decently. That's exactly the kind of experiment AI made possible for me.

If that's what you want to do on your own time, that's fine. But it doesn't mean you had to submit it to a game jam where people were actually coding their games, drawing the art pixel by pixel, etc. Not to be harsh, but people using AI took a shortcut. The goal of using AI was to put themselves above the real work other people put into their games

We're regular people, not studios, and a jam only gives us a few months. 

That's the  point of a jam: to see what people can do within limits. That's especially true for a retro game jam where you're also handling the limits of the console. Circumventing the limits by using AI would be like hiring a professional team to do the game for you. It's no longer impressive or exciting. You took a shortcut and you're not showing what you and your collaborators can do, you're showing what you can get someone or something else to do for you

I always thought a jam was about trying crazy ideas within a limited time, not about entering games people have been working on for years. Honestly, that feels even less fair to me than using AI.

At least those people learned and grew as people by learning the process. But either way, if a game jam has a time limit, that time limit is part of what makes the jam what it is. If we can use AI code and art, why not just decompile super Mario world, recompile it, and submit that? Because we all know Super Mario World is in the training data. Or why can't I use code from games I made in the past if I can use code from other people's games stolen and repackaged by AI? 

It doesn't make sense

(+1)

Thanks for sharing your view. I think we just value different things in a jam, and that's fine. For me, getting past my fear and finally making a SNES game was a big personal step, even if I used different tools than you would. AI was allowed this year and I was open about using it. Whatever the hosts decide for next year, I'll respect it. Good luck with your entry!

Thanks you too

(+1)

Beautifully said.

Thank you :)