Thank you for sharing your perspective, Frosties! It's an interesting situation and I'm not really sure what the right solution is.
"In the end, we all want the same thing: more and better SNES games."
I disagree here, actually! I think there are a wide variety of reasons that people might join the jam and that this is just one of them. There's been some good discussion (and some not so good name-calling haha) on the Discord related to this same point.
For me personally, I've always been intrinsically motivated to understand my code and the system it's running on. This worked well for me because, historically, having that understanding and mastery of a system was complementary (or required!) to pursuing the extrinsic motivation of impressing others by tackling the difficult task of creating a SNES game. Two birds with one stone.
With AI, however, understanding is becoming more and more orthogonal to getting things done. You no longer need understanding or mastery to create.
A lot of the gen-AI games submitted this year are quite impressive! Or, at least, they are impressive by the pre-AI standards of what made a SNES game impressive. Maybe we have to update our standards now, but then that also feels like it moves the bar for people who choose not to use AI. I know that my non-AI game looks a lot less impressive than most of the AI games in this jam (and most of the non-AI games 😅). I still got a lot of enjoyment from pursuing my intrinsic motivation, but I would be lying if I said it didn't sting a bit to see the AI competition. Maybe that's my own fault for caring about the extrinsic motivation.
I think it's also worth mentioning that understanding and mastery are just one portion of a game jam. The games also have to be fun and unique! AI isn't great at that yet, so it does feel like games are on a more level playing field in that regard.
For me, I think it would be nice to continue having a jam where understanding and mastery are a primary goal. Maybe that's this jam, maybe that's some other jam. Maybe AI will become so ubiquitous in software dev that in a couple years this'll all be a moot point 😅
I did want to push back a little on your comment around people submitting games they've been working on for years. That's not allowed in this jam. Or maybe I'm misunderstanding your comment? Apologies if so!
I definitely don't mean to single you out with this reply! I think Super Tourmalet is a cool idea and looks quite nice :) And I'm also glad you enjoyed the jam! I did as well :D