Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+3)

I have a lot...  A LOT to say, so let me start with this:

I'm interested in this. Certainly more than your other games at least (sorry to say). I'm intrigued as to where you'll take this and how far it'll go. It seems like you already have around 50 girls if that one screenshot is anything to go by.

So know that I'm going to be saying a lot *because* I'm interested.

On that note, I have no idea how much you already have planned, what equipment you plan to have that could completely change units, what balance changes you already have in mind, if any, what units/attackers you'll add, if any, and what changes to the prestige tree you'll make. I have no idea on any of this, so take everything I'm about to say with that in mind, cause I have no idea what you already have in your mind.


Let me start by going over the units from least to most useful.

Harpies. Completely pointless. They only do damage, and even fully buffed, they don't do nearly as much as the top two. If I may make a suggestion, maybe you can give them a niche in being a super-fast attacker? Essentially making them a 'chance-procer'. But this is me not knowing if you have some absurd equipment down the line for them.

Archers. Almost completely pointless. They do the most damage that isn't from the top two, but it's still almost an order of magnitude lower. Their best trait is attacking a lot, quickly, but this just procs the 1000% buff, which is just better on the top two, and procs doom... which I'll talk more about with Wizards. But it's useless.

Knights. Have some use in two ways; Being the early game attacker to get you started, and giving out that bleeding debuff that does percentile damage on top of other sources. If you want a quick early game, you upgrade knights. You want a 'buff' that remains useful throughout? Upgrade, keep, and use the Goat Horn with knights. Other then that though, again... there's no reason to buff their damage thereafter. They don't even reach archer's damage, which themselves, I already said had pointless damage.

Wizards. Are... really weird. I don't know why you even bothered with damage buffs for wizards when they're the weakest attackers in the game (of which their buffs DO NOT compensate) and their main abilities have nothing to do with their damage. Speaking of, both Fire and Doom are useless. Even with the 'Arcana' buffs, they both just do not compare in damage to the top two... again. Like... doom, even with the Demon Mask and everything upgraded does like... a couple million. I'd seriously consider making Doom procs be multiplied by wizard damage on top OR make it a percentage damage thing and rework all the buffs to it. The only reasons that Wizards are above knights is because of Paralyze (and it being allowed to get to such a high buff) and Dryad Vines. If they were missing one of these two, or both were significantly weaker, I'd seriously consider Knights as being better.

Then there's the top two. I could make arguments for either being the top, but for this demo...

The Angel. Is... very weak at the start. It takes a good bit to even get to them, and if you don't have that vaguely described arcana buff, they just don't do anything at first. But you also get the angel right when the economy is starting to blow up to billions thanks to the Treent Stump, so you end up fully upgrading it's damage buff and level cap in no time. (Also, I don't really understand the point of the resetting level cap when it does so little damage and you can just ignore it by upgrading to full right away.) From there... well it's the only exponentially increasing attacker in the game. Even without the arcana buff, it still beats the top pick at around level 8. If this demo had a couple more monsters, but nothing about attackers changed, the angel would be the sole reason you could beat those monsters.

The Catapult. It's funny, at first play, it doesn't seem so good, with it's still comparable damage to the other sources, and then it's automated version hits you in the face with the fact it can *MISS*, making you feel like an idiot for getting the upgrade (which, by the way, I'm surprised there's nothing that affects that)... but then... it does more damage. Then more. And then it keeps doing more. And then you find that the majority of this demo is completely beaten by the Catapult's damage curve. Your other units will make the HP bar go down in pixels while this thing either one shots or takes out gigantic chunks. Without arcane upgrades, but with all the equipment buffs, this thing can do a billion damage per minute. While most everything else is struggling to do millions. I wasn't joking about 'order of magnitude difference' when I was talking about archers.

I have no idea if the Catapult is overtuned, or if everything else is just weak. With the fact it'd be difficult to get through this demo without it, I'm inclined to say the latter.


Now some final points. Research is annoying right now. I don't know if this is just a 'demo-limit' thing where you've limited on how much buildings can be upgraded in this demo compared to the full game, but Research feels the worst. Both Wizards and Angels (no, I'm not even considering Harpies) take A LOT of it. But you're only allowed to produce so much... and then you make the Arcana buffs to research be behind *four* nodes, with them being the most expensive... despite being minor buffs... why?

Finally, the big system, Equipment and Material upgrades. I do actually like the whole 'upgrading equipment with materials' thing, despite some annoyance sometimes when you just don't get the drop you want for a while. My 'problem' is just in that, once you've gotten all the upgrades, the materials just kinda stay rotting in your inventory. There's a couple things I think you could do. Simplest would be to just make them sellable. Give them a value, right click to sell. You could also have a 'crafting' system where you could take multiple of a weaker material to make a stronger one. Like 3 Elf Ears to 1 Elf Ribbon, then 3 Elf Ribbons to 1 Goat Tail. Or something like that. Would certainly make upgrading some equipment less annoying.

Or... if you're willing to listen to a crazy idea... let equipment just... keep upgrading. Let the Magic Earrings be buffed all the way to dryad leaves. Obviously, this would take quite a bit to make sure no buff breaks and you might even need to make some buffs just stop upgrading at certain points, and you'll probably want to make upgrade materials of a higher tier give a greater effect for some equipment, like the Elf Earrings... and it doesn't really solve the problems of stuff cluttering... ok yeah, I just wanted to see crazy buffs, you got me. If you did actually do this, you'll probably want to also grab one of the other 'use for materials' points.

Anyways, sorry for the long rant. At least you know I really am interested and care.

If I had to give just one little piece of advice, based on what I've seen, you should really pay attention to exponentials and how much even a single order of magnitude in difference really is.

(+1)

I was going to write something similar myself but you captured most of my points. Catapult is just way more powerful than anything else. Although I'd put Wizards at second-most useful simply because not only can their Paralyze increase the damage of the catapult, I imagine that them with Dryad Vines would likely be near-mandatory to include for going after the later monsters due to percent-of-max-hp damage, although I haven't played enough to see the Angel get maxed out (nor gotten the Ascendant Angel upgrade).

I'm similarly baffled by the upgrade tree: why lock research rate upgrades behind all the Farm stuff? Why lock the church upgrades behind the wizard tower ones that aren't useful at all early-game?  It makes the feeling of progression less gradual and measured, and more "nothing changes one run, then big boosts next run"

Oh, and also... I think the reason the auto-catapult can miss is to make it so that there's always a reason to manually use it so you don't have to go totally Idle-game on it, since you can hit nice/great hits every time.