This game was a surprise, I actually got engaged with the gameplay and plot, normally when sex games have non-sexual gameplay sections I'm annoyed and just want them to end as quickly as possible. Not so with this game.
That said, I am not a fan of the writing. Every other dialogue gave me vague redpill vibes (and sometimes not so vague). Eventually I pretty much checked out of the story and invented my own. I couldnt relate to any of the characters' attitudes or worries or intentions or how they reacted to things, and this got progressively worse until I could no longer take any of it seriously (currently at post-hydroponics).
Vivian's character and growth are a particular sore point. I do not buy that in the situation she's in, her primary concern is that she missed her chance to have a serious relationship while she had an organic body. And the bitchy attitude she constantly gives us during the early sections of the game has no payoff, it's just annoying and unnecessary.
It would have been a better story if Vivian was open about her fetishes from the start, and her inner conflict was about having given Aemi her own fetishes and a promiscuous attitude during a late night moment of lust-clouded brain at work, after the scientists had already given up on the project ever succeeding. So now she's horrified that she turned humanity's first true AI into a bondage and chastity slut (instead of this being spontaneous / accidental / flimsily explained), and doubly horrified that the station analyzed her brain during the transfer and 3D-printed all the sex toys and restraints for the tests based on her fantasies (instead of that gear already being what was intended to be used during the tests 50 years ago).
So instead of having a prudish disapproval of the player until she suddenly doesnt anymore, she starts out feeling intensely humiliated and has to be coaxed into letting herself enjoy her sexuality the way Aemi is so eager to do. And the relationship with the players grows "naturally", for lack of a better word, from having to spend so much intimate time together, instead of having extremely awkward conversations where they reassure each other that they're awesome and that's why they're going to be / stay together.
Like, after a "testing" session, instead of getting immediately rescued by Aemi, have the player give "aftercare" to Vivian by assuring her that he doesnt think any less of her for having watched her get subjected to that humiliation, nor for having watched her actually get off on being violated. Then she falls asleep in his arms. Have them go through at least 3 mandatory "testing" sessions like that.
Then during the free roam stages of the game, she first comes to terms with having to become the player's pretend sexbot to dodge the authorities, then becomes envious of Aemi just having fun with her body and fetishes with no shame, so she becomes determined to open up and learn to enjoy life.
It would also help to have separate "appropriate" and casual outfit sets. Right now the game takes all toys off at the start of a mission, but it keeps the outfit, which typically results in both girls being mostly or completely naked during missions, making the gameplay feel unserious. Then it keeps that outfit on during scripted dialogues after a mission, before the player can freely interact with the girls to change it, resulting in the "serious" plot dialogues also feeling unserious.
So each character should have a mission outfit slot, for which only the more dignified outfits are available, and they should change into it at the start of a mission (and get forced out of it during "tests", before putting it back on), then stay in it when we return to the hangar until the scripted plot stuff is done, then at the end of the dialogue ask the player to help them switch back into their casual outfit (with all toys automatically re-equipped), signalling to the player that they're back in free roam mode.
I also feel that Aemi's interactions with the player and Vivian's attitude towards them could use a lot of work. Right now a lot of the dialogue is Aemi reassuring the player of the same thing about 200 times. While trying to think of how it could be improved, I remembered Saffron from Firefly. It seems like that kind of humorous approach might benefit this story - Aemi only knows about relationships from the internet, so she goes around doing stereotypical "girlfriend" things, like cooking for us, without any regard for what the player has to say about it. Meanwhile Vivian is looking at the scene disapprovingly with her arms crossed (but isnt bitching to us about it, since Aemi is doing it by her own initiative) and the player character is left exasperated.
I think doing it that way - with Aemi taking the lead and not even waiting for the player's response, just doing it while the player is trying to explain that it isnt necessary - would work better to resolve the issue of exploitation, which the game currently spends an excessive amount of time revisiting constantly with dialogue where Aemi explicitly states her desire to do the things she's doing. Theoretically this "enthusiastic consent" should be a good thing, but it ends up feeling hollow because the real source of the "icky" feeling about this relationship is the question of whether Aemi is competent to give consent given her inexperience.
So we reframe it from the player feeling like they're doing things to Aemi, and constantly questioning whether it's appropriate to do those things despite Aemi wanting to do them and giving explicit consent, to feeling like Aemi is doing things to the player, so the question of consent falls on him, he can stop her by saying no, but he likes what she's doing so he lets her do it.
In terms of sex this would be Aemi sometimes coming up and saying "Can I kiss you?" and then groping us during the kiss, and other times just coming up behind the player and grabbing us from behind and fondling us, in either case she then pulls our pants down, and we have a choice of:
- "let her continue" (she lays us down on the nearest bed and straddles us)
- "take her to the nearest bed" (we lay her down and pick a position)
- "take her right here" (standing sex, pick between front and back)
- "On your knees." (blowjob)
- "No, stop." (the sex scene ends)
The first few times, the player character says something along the lines of "we shouldnt be doing this", and she counters that it looks like he wants to while squeezing his erection.
We should also have a few opportunities to say "No, stop." where it's obviously the right call to make, just to establish that the player isnt completely passive in this and CAN stop her if he wants to.
Edit: And in terms of why Aemi chooses to stay with the player rather than seeking someone better, instead of having her give a weird explanation about the sexual marketplace (or however it was phrased), have her at first say something humorous along the lines of "Based on my research of human media, it is common for a woman to develop romantic feelings towards a man who rescued her, and you rescued me". And then towards the end of the story the MC shares his fear of abandonment and she reassures him that the bond and trust they've developed over the past weeks make him more desirable than any other potential partner, and she does not want to lose him.