the moment the fireplace went cold when i blew out the lantern made me want to check every room twice. then i ran out of oil and finally saw those red marks on the door while the person outside was asking to get out of the rain. that made the questions feel a lot more tense than a simple open or dont open choice.
id give the first knock a short subtitle that names the front hall if hints are on. i followed the stairs toward the kitchen on my first loop and used nearly all my oil before i found the right end of the hall. a little movement in the light under the front door could point you there without a marker. i waited at the door and got the first memory by rereading the note in the dark on the next loop which was a cool payoff for checking the same spot again. the option to open the door moved from 5 to 3 as i asked questions though so id keep it on a fixed key or give it a separate confirm to avoid an accidental choice.
if you want to trade playtests my game is purr or treat: the midnight reef. a rating and your take on what the game makes clear in its first few minutes would be great.