Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Would you pay for game music per player instead of a flat fee?

A topic by onem0 created 12 days ago Views: 156 Replies: 6
Viewing posts 1 to 2

Hi all, I'm building a music licensing service for games and would like to hear from people who actually make and release games before I go further. It isn't open yet, so there's no link, I'm only asking.

The idea: independent artists license complete tracks (no sound effects) for games. While you build, licences are free (30 days, renewable). When you release, you pay a small entry price per song, then a small amount for every player who hears that song for the first time, counted by an SDK in the game (Unity first). It works the same in every store and business model, free games included, and players never need an account. The artist earns from every player instead of getting a one-off fee.

As an example: €0.50 entry and 0.5 cents per player. A song in a game that 10,000 people play would then cost €0.50 + €50 in total.

What I'd like to know:

1. Where does your music come from today (asset packs, a composer, free/CC music), and roughly what did it cost you?

2. Would per-player pricing put you off compared to a flat fee? Would you need a cap per song or per game?

3. If your game is free, would this make sense for you at all, or only for paid games?

4. Would an SDK that reports first listens be a deal-breaker (offline play, privacy, web builds)?

5. Which engine do you use?

Honest answers are welcome, including "I'd never use this, and here's why." Thanks!

(+1)

1. Mostly purchased or free from itch.io
2. Yes.
3. It doesn't make sense for free or paid games.
4. Yes.
5. Unity

You're over-estimating the value of music in games. A lot of people simply turn it off or never turn it on. On your model the person would pay a license fee for a song that was switched on, and that the player immediately turned off. Monitoring and collecting your money would be a nightmare.  

Thank you for your Reply. Helped a lot. I will keep that in mind. 

Hi onem0 — the per-player pricing question is one I've been thinking about from the creator side, so happy to add a data point rather than just cheerleading.


From what I've shipped (packs priced free / $5 / $9 with a paid tier on the asset side), the pattern I keep seeing is that buyers of asset packs are rarely paying per active player — they're paying to unblock themselves on a specific art problem, and they'll happily pay a one-time fee if it's clearly the cheaper path. Per-player pricing makes more sense when the ongoing value is the content itself and your player base is much larger than your asset buyer base.


The middle option that works well for packs is a pay-what-you-want floor: it keeps the free tier doing its job (search ranking, portfolio, first-touch) while letting teams that clearly have budget pay more than the listed price.


Happy to compare notes on what the actual numbers look like for you.

Hi onem0 — the per-player pricing question is one I've been thinking about from the creator side, so happy to add a data point rather than just cheerleading.


From what I've shipped (packs priced free / $5 / $9 with a paid tier on the asset side), the pattern I keep seeing is that buyers of asset packs are rarely paying per active player — they're paying to unblock themselves on a specific art problem, and they'll happily pay a one-time fee if it's clearly the cheaper path. Per-player pricing makes more sense when the ongoing value is the content itself and your player base is much larger than your asset buyer base.


The middle option that works well for packs is a pay-what-you-want floor: it keeps the free tier doing its job (search ranking, portfolio, first-touch) while letting teams that clearly have budget pay more than the listed price.


Happy to compare notes on what the actual numbers look like for you.

Hi onem0 — the per-player pricing question is one I've been thinking about from the creator side, so happy to add a data point rather than just cheerleading.


From what I've shipped (packs priced free / $5 / $9 with a paid tier on the asset side), the pattern I keep seeing is that buyers of asset packs are rarely paying per active player — they're paying to unblock themselves on a specific art problem, and they'll happily pay a one-time fee if it's clearly the cheaper path. Per-player pricing makes more sense when the ongoing value is the content itself and your player base is much larger than your asset buyer base.


The middle option that works well for packs is a pay-what-you-want floor: it keeps the free tier doing its job (search ranking, portfolio, first-touch) while letting teams that clearly have budget pay more than the listed price.


Happy to compare notes on what the actual numbers look like for you.

Hi onem0 — the per-player pricing question is one I've been thinking about from the creator side, so happy to add a data point rather than just cheerleading.


From what I've shipped (packs priced free / $5 / $9 with a paid tier on the asset side), the pattern I keep seeing is that buyers of asset packs are rarely paying per active player — they're paying to unblock themselves on a specific art problem, and they'll happily pay a one-time fee if it's clearly the cheaper path. Per-player pricing makes more sense when the ongoing value is the content itself and your player base is much larger than your asset buyer base.


The middle option that works well for packs is a pay-what-you-want floor: it keeps the free tier doing its job (search ranking, portfolio, first-touch) while letting teams that clearly have budget pay more than the listed price.


Happy to compare notes on what the actual numbers look like for you.