Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Feedback wanted on my 2D character packs: is the quality and pricing right?

A topic by Tiny Tileset created 19 hours ago Views: 35 Replies: 3
Viewing posts 1 to 4
(1 edit)

Hi everyone! I make cartoon 2D character packs for top-down games under the name Tiny Tileset, and I'd love honest feedback before I make more.

My page: https://tinytileset.itch.io

The newest pack is Undead Hollow: 10 rigged undead with walk, idle and attack in 4 directions, 38 effects and 59 icons, priced at $9.99. My other packs are between $5.99 and $7.99, and each one has a free Lite version with one character.

Free sample to try: https://tinytileset.itch.io/undead-hollow-lite

What I'd like to know:

1. Pricing: does $9.99 feel fair for what's inside, too high, or too low?

2. Quality: do the animations look smooth and natural? Anything that looks stiff or off?

3. Page: do the cover and previews make it clear what you get?

4. Usability: if you try the free sample, do the files drop into your engine easily (Godot, Unity, GameMaker, RPG Maker)?

5. What's missing: more animations (hurt, death), more directions, smaller frame sizes?

Harsh feedback is fine, I'd rather hear it now. Thanks!

You asked for harsh, so the biggest thing first: both the Undead Hollow page and the Lite page show "No generative AI was used" in the Content row, but your post says the artwork is made with AI tools. itch's quality guidelines say they strictly enforce the AI disclosure on game asset pages and that untagged pages may be delisted, so I'd switch it to yes (Graphics) on every pack before a buyer or a mod spots the mismatch. You can still say in the description that you cut, rig and animate everything yourself, since that's a big part of what people are paying for.

On price, $9.99 for 10 creatures in 4 directions with about 2,200 frames, 38 effects and the grave kit doesn't look high next to your $5.99 to $7.99 packs, and a free Lite per pack is a good way to let people test the import first. Small detail: the full page says 59 icons and the Lite page says 60, so pick one number. If you add anything, I'd go for hurt and death on every creature, since right now only the bat and the dragon list a hurt animation and none list death, and most top-down games need both for enemies.

Thanks a lot for the feedback . I will fix those right away. Thanks again

Moderator moved this topic to Get Feedback
Moderator

(moved to the right category)