I think this is an interesting concept, and choosing dialogue by picking a side is a neat idea. I did find it frustrating at times, though. With so many ways to die, a few save points would make repeated attempts feel less discouraging and help keep me motivated to see the game through.
The Enter key also threw me off at first. I didn’t realize it triggered the automatic dialogue choice, so I was confused when trying to select the other option. Making that clearer, or using a different key, would help. I’d have enjoyed exploring the concept more with those adjustments!