Have been seeing your game in discord for a while now and just finally got to played this game, and I see why this game sit as one of the most rated games in the jam. The art is so charming and lovely and instantly drew the eye, and the overall aesthestics stood out a lot among all the entries in the jam. The game also felt really polished and professionally made, and is abundantly clear that you've all poured your heart and soul into the game. That alone is already extremely impressive.
Speaking of gameplay and theming, it seems to have some cult of the lamb influence along side the metacritic of religion, and is doing it nicely without being too preachy. I quite like how lucky number is used in the game, even though it steered away from what we normal think of lucky number. A sacred number perhaps? Anyway I digress. I also like the fact that you've put in a lot of effort making a quite in-depth system with character perks, weathers etc, and it is such a shame that in a jam where most people are playing no longer than an hour would fully apperciate how the system works.
My biggest criticism on this game (and a lot of the games in the jam for that matter, so don't feel too bad about it) is that it's really luck dependent, and there's no real strategy of choosing a prophecy (or at least it felt there is no, which if you think about it it's basically the same) and it doesn't feel the choice you made had an impact to the outcome. It baiscally boils down to a 1/12 chance of getting doubted or believed. I would hope the game require some data analysis that improves the chance of fullfilling a prophecy. This effect was worsen by you having to pick a prophecy each day, which just made the gambling aspect worse. (Or you can blame me not liking gambling games in general, which, fair you can call me biased) But I do like the concept of the prophecy mechanic and in general is one of the most creative way to interpret the theme. So, with all that said, well done on making the game, and hope you get the ranking you deserved.
Other things I like:
- The dialogue is funny
- Map and UI looks really great
- Using AI as a last resort instead of fully embrasing it. Love to see people still doing that, there's just too much AI in this jam than I am happy with
- Good tutorial sequence to on board the player with
Suggestions:
- The font is probably the biggest drawback of the game. Gothics is cool and I like it a lot, but using it as the main font with that much reading is just a pain. It would take at least double to triple time to undestand and slow down the already slow game
- Map movement is extremely slow, speeding it up would be great, alongside allowing the player to use the mouse and drag the map instead
- 30 days is also a looooong period. It will probably took over an hour just to finish the game. It's not bad for a regular game but as a jam game too long and being too repetitve is definitely a minus. I do see you've add a fast forward button to make time goes faster, but it could be much faster
- I will especially comment on the prophecy creation UI, where although it looks nice, the character took too much screen real estate doing nothing, while the other UI with huge amount of information got squeezed to ocupying 1/3 of the screen instead. How the heck am I suppose to analysis when there's only 5 event worth of worklog visible at a given time. I will suggest making the character the background of the UI, and showing him/her during the claim animation to add a bit of flavour
