Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Wow, thank you! This is exactly the kind of feedback I was hoping for. Really glad you played through it twice and took the time to write all this.

The land/reclamation balance is definitely something I need to look at. If you never even came close to running out of space, then that whole part of the game isn't creating any interesting decisions.

And I completely agree about the annex. I don't want players to reach a point where they've done everything and are just staring at a timer. Ideally, construction and other progression should overlap much better.

I also like the idea of a speed control. I'm trying to find that balance between a relaxing idle game and having enough things to do when you actually want to play.

As for what comes after restructuring, I'm thinking about expanding into new locations, each with its own look, challenges and economics, while your previous businesses continue generating income. Still figuring out the details, but I'd love to make it feel like you're slowly building an increasingly ridiculous funeral empire.

By the way, I've just redesigned the entire management interface! All the construction and business decisions now live in a separate Operations screen, with Death himself behind the desk making sarcastic comments. It frees up much more room to actually watch the cemetery. You might enjoy checking out the latest devlog :)

Seriously, thanks again. Comments like yours are incredibly useful, especially this early in development. And good luck with your own project when you get around to making it!

You are welcome.  I tend to overanalyze everything and sometimes that's useful.

I was thinking about the Annex, could make it a multi-stage build that requires each construction to be of a certain level.  Like L1 across the board let's you start it, L2 does another 15%, L3, L4, etc., L5 is the final stretch.  
If the player branches out to other companies, then repeating this wait might not be that big of a deal since they'd be able to jump over to a different company if I understand what you meant.

As far as the speed control, I was thinking something like Sims games where you can jump to two or three times speed and back to normal. And to be clear, I'm not asking for specific changes, just voicing my thoughts.  I promise I will not be rude if you do exactly what you want to do with your own game. 

I'll check out the changes and let you know if anything comes to mind.

I think you've identified something real with the Annex. It's not necessarily that construction takes too long, but that by the time you start it, you've already upgraded everything and there's nothing meaningful left to do except wait. (i mean this IS alpha version but still)

I really like your suggestion of building it gradually alongside the department upgrades. That would make progression feel much more natural, with overlapping goals instead of one big waiting period at the end.

Our longer-term idea is to let players expand into different cemeteries, each with its own challenges, while previous operations keep earning money. So eventually there should be plenty to keep you busy while something is being built elsewhere.

Nothing set in stone yet, but this is exactly the kind of feedback that helps us figure out what the full game should become. Thanks again for putting so much thought into it! :) We make patches almost daily now so expect something soon .. 

Hope the team's doing well.

I started a fresh run in a different browser so here as some notes.  It being an alpha, I've been trying to focus on specific gameplay as opposed to polish and QoL things.  

Moving everything to the Operations tab does tidy up the interface.  The amount of money doesn't show up on it though which requires clicking back and forth if a player has enough money to make multiple purchases but hasn't planned them all out.  Similarly, knowing how many bats are left during the build phases on the cemetery screen would be useful. I do really appreciate that the bats repeat until the number is up instead of only getting the one chance.  

I started the Annex as soon as everything his L4 and I had the 240 burials, to see how long of a wait there was.  It's possible a nudge to starting it earlier than I did initially might be all that's needed.  I was at 65-70% with all other departments specialized.  I think a wait here is good, as far as the pacing of the game goes, but I had enough time to build up funds for every specialization and still another few minutes wait to be able to restructure.  It wasn't terrible and didn't push me away from the game in real life, I just mention it to follow up.

Speaking of specialization, I picked based on the higher number per minute instead of the pros/cons.  I set my policy to Upselling as I always had an abundance of customers.  There's a section where you can control the line I think, but I never touched it.  I assume this is all stuff that's being worked on the in Alpha phase, so I don't really have much to add aside from I noticed it, I just didn't really engage with it. Same as I never had a 'mishap' while transporting a coffin or any other negative instance during the whole play through.  I assume these are obstacles that will appear over time.

I had another idea about the graves and scarcity: use the same pool for every or multiple companies.  Like the player's first three cemeteries all "physically" connect to the same location, and then the player leases another central repository when they branch out further (depending on how far and which direction you take the game, of course).  Playing from scratch again, I can definitely say the early game graves situation feels right.  Having to buy the two upgrades to get to the reclamation to do the contract is a good flow.  I just never needed to upgrade again, especially after I maxed out reclaim.   Once I got any of the restructure upgrades, that is when it became less consequential.  I didn't want to overshadow the early game experience as I started the overall conversation with it.

I think that's about it for the main gameplay.  It really is an surprisingly engaging loop.  I'll keep following along and drop any thoughts/feel free to ask direct questions. 

There are a couple of QoL/polish things worth mentioning:
An in-game hard reset would be useful.  It's easy to open a different browser or privacy tab to play from scratch, the option in game is nice.
I don't know the correct term for it, but it in the background, past the building and the trees, there's the layer that looks like clouds.  It has an obvious stitch in the graphic.  I put it in polish because I don't think people will be complaining, I just noticed it.  Same with the Transportation department. When it gets to the conveyor belt, the animation looks a bit off. Overall, though, the graphics are very impressive.  There's a rich depth that doesn't seem to bog down my browser.  

It's a really fun loop.  Will definitely keep playing to see how it comes along.

Hey!

Thanks again for another full playthrough..... *really* appreciate all these detailed observations.

A few of your suggestions are already in the new update we've just pushed because they were on sptrint list.  Money is now visible in Operations (that was annoying me too!), there's a funeral progress bar to show how fast your business is running, and bats now have a 5/5 counter, get faster with each level, and give some visual feedback when caught. We also added three save slots and a little nudge to start the Annex earlier.

The balancing points are really interesting too. I agree that specializations and policies should involve more meaningful decisions, and I love your shared cemetery capacity idea for future locations. Still plenty to work on, including that conveyor animation!

One question since you've spent so many hours with the game: how do you feel about the music? Would you enjoy having maybe three different themes rotating, or would that become distracting in an idle game?

Thanks again, seriously. This kind of feedback is incredibly helpful!

Funny thing, I played it silent the whole time.  When I'm on here or galaxy, most often the tab itself is muted and I've got something else on to listen to.  I do appreciate a very easy to access and legible audio menu.  Some games don't even have the option, let alone sliders.  But there were some changes made, so I left the sound on to check them out.

Firstly, the tone is very on theme.  Good choice there. I like how the cemetery music comes and goes. As far as variation, the one that plays feels very evening and night time.  Having a variation that has more of a morning, daytime feel that plays randomly.  Still keep the silence broken by music, just the one that plays is based on the in game time.  I didn't find the current level of music lacking.

The new bat animations/variations are more challenging.  Again, I appreciate that the player can miss a cycle without losing the chance.  The tension is there without a harsh punishment.  Having the building and level in the bat counter was surprisingly helpful.  I always appreciate information-at-a-glance, so knowing what's being built without having to dig into the menus is nice.  

I kicked off the Annex as soon as I was able. It actually completed before all my building were L5.  I could restructure at the moment and get 10 shares.  Instead I let it run to full construction and could restructure at 22.  That's another thing I appreciate about the loop.  If the player is impatient or just curious what it feels like after restructure, they can, or wait longer and be rewarded for it.  I have it on a different monitor while I type this and it's already up to 44.  

I also appreciated ya'll taking this as intended.  It's really easy for me to critique stuff and sometimes I come across as "you should" instead of "you could" or overly negative.  Always been long-winded, so the problem compounds.  I'm still sketching out an idea for my own game, and as you might be able to guess, I get stuck in my own weeds a lot.  But this site and the access devs like you provide to games has been very helpful in narrowing down my own vision.  Just have to put together a lot of skills and lash something together.  Should be fun.

I am not asking for a personal reminder of every patch, but you are welcome to nudge in the comments if any more specific questions comes up. Thanks for the time.

Hey!

Dont worry about being too critical. You've helped us make the game better.

And about your own game, I really hope you go for it! If you ever need help, want to bounce ideas around, or just need a second opinion, don't hesitate to ask.  (I have a played a lot of games sinve '86 and my C64 :) )

Really hope we get to play it someday.