Gameplay: I had a hard time understanding the fishing game and I think it's a core part of progressing the game :( Maybe in the fishing game, you can put a dialogue text or say something on how to fish to help the player?
I didn't catch the fish...
and when the voice said "Well, I'll be damned", I don't know why but I found it funny! ( ≧ᗜ≦)
Fishing was soo hard T___T But maybe that reflects the reality of fishing. I wanted to get the different types of fishes... Maybe make the fishing game a bit less punishing for the next update? :P
Narrative: I found it poetic ♡ I wish I could have read the other entries, but I'm guessing it's linked to fishing. I know the journal was already read out loud, but a bigger text when reading it again would be nice.
This was me reading the journal

Visuals: That was such a cool intro at the start! I like taking in the scenery. In fact, the first thing I did was stray away from the path and just kept walking around the woods until I hit the boundary. It was quite relaxing with the rain ambience.
I'm gonna do a bit of self-promotion here because I like leaves and made a free assets pack of them. You can check it out: Free Autumn Leaves (It's not pixel art, though, so might not fit this game...)
Sound: Amazing! I don't know why, but the main menu music gave me the vibes of "false comfort". Like it's calming, but there are parts that seem "horror" to me. Not sure how to explain it exactly..
With that said, with this music, you can probably pivot to a horror game where you are not just someone lost in the woods, you are someone finding dead bodies of previously "lost" travellers and finding their personal effects... Man, that would creepy but fascinating to play!
OH! And the voice acting, too! It was immersive, like listening to an audiobook!
Theme: I definitely did take in the scenery! Well done!
ദ്ദി(˵ •̀ ᴗ - ˵ ) ✧
Edit: OH! I just realised this was team-made! Well done to everyone involved!