I enjoyed this game, very cute but a bit short. I like the idea but I wish you would've done more with it, here's a few suggestions I have:
1 - Allow the player to restart the game by pressing a button, maybe R, because I found myself many times to put the wrong ingredient in and then I had to wait for the round to restart. Or actually it would be even funnier if the cauldron exploded if you put the wrong ingredient in lol

2 - You should add more depth to the items you find, for example in the second level when I saw that you needed to throw in a "bloody knife" and I saw the normal knife on the table I imagined I'd have to use the knife on something to get blood on it, but then I saw there was a different bloody knife. What i'm trying to say is it would've been cooler if you leaned more into the puzzle aspect of the game, where you had to do something to get the items you needed, instead of just looking for them, for example I really liked what you did on the last level by hiding the cake! 

3 - Some music would've been really cool, even if you don't make it

That's my 2 cents, overall I really enjoyed the game and i'm curious to see how it would look in the future if you were to expand on it

 I couldn't figure out the last level but I had a lot of fun with the first two levels. I think it's a great idea. Nice job!

A fine game but that last levels solution was not fun at all since it is not intuitive to the player that the object can be hidden. Previous levels the object is in always in plain sight but this one feels cheap by hiding it.

This is a really cool take on the theme and well done too. The gameplay and HUD/UI art is all matching and consistent. I love that, it really adds to the overal game. 5/5 nice work!

Also I'd appreciate feedback on my submission if you get a chance!

Nice little item finding game. It was kinda funny to imagine what kind of potion the wizard was trying to make with a grand piano. Also a small thing but when he picked it up it also slows him down quite a bit, so that's a small nice detail.

The art looks ok, but some things seem out of place with the other things. The music is nice, but it seemed to not loop when the song ends.

SPOILER: I got stumped on the piece of cake level. My first intuition is obviously picking up the knife and brought it to the big cake, but there's no prompt saying that you can slice it or anything, so I looked around a bit, but I'm not sure what I was supposed to do next. Now some games are actually also like this, like the old point-and-click adventure games I used to play back in the days, where you sort of click random things until you got the right things or you trigger some sort of events to progress the story. But in those games there are loads of things to do, so it didn't feel boring when you got a little stuck, whereas in your game is very simple, so these sorts of roadblocks are major hurdles and honestly will turn off a lot of people.

Cool puzzle with search for objects. There is humor, I like it. Cool graphics, good sounds. I did not have enough time to remember the things that need to be found, maybe make a stop of time? And the first level should remove the timer altogether, otherwise it is not immediately clear what needed to be done.