Hi, thanks so much for playing! Regarding that little bug — thanks for the feedback, but actually the Paladin can vote for the Vengeful (the Paladin just can't vote for the Rat or another Paladin, and votes for a soldier who voted for an innocent one). Hope that clears things up! In the future, if you run into any bugs, feel free to post a screenshot of the board setup so we can help you troubleshoot.