Great game concept and soundtrack! I wrote down my thoughts while listening to each track:

Small Gnomes - At first, I felt this track was missing something, then I realized this was an introduction to the theme, while Plotting Gnomes is the fleshed out “reprise” version, so no criticism there.

Town Plaza - I do love an accordion and polka rhythms. I appreciate that you took the time to record live instruments because I understand it introduces other challenges, especially within the time constraint. This is a great track already, though one thing I would try in order to develop this further is to have 4 or 8 bars where the arrangement shrinks down then builds back up.

Lute Girl - Lovely progression, reminiscent of Spanish flamenco.

Daybreak - Nice interplay between the melodic lines here.

Plotting Gnomes - My favorite track. Good use of dynamics, part writing, harmonizing lines, and form of the piece.

Goodnight - I like the way you used percussion here. A sweet farewell piece for this soundtrack.

I really enjoyed listening to your soundtrack which conveys a playful energy, motivic development, and good variety to tell a complete story. Nice work!

I like how charming all the songs are. Even when the gnomes are revealed to be evil, it doesn't take itself too seriously and I appreciate that.

The songs are short and sweet and get their points across well. 

Sometimes it feels like the songs might be lacking a bit in terms of complexity, but they are still fun to listen to and I like how you explained how you incorporated the story in the music with keys and melody inversions.

Seconded carrot and kaz - I've gotta say Lute Girl was my favorite as well, and Plotting Gnomes had me wondering, "what if all those hours I played Barony were fun instead of stressful?"

I like the whimsical feel this ost has! personal favorite is lute girl just because of how calming it is as well as the melody :)

Neat submission! Love the air of gnomish mischief especially.