More like plate-forme pixel art type
Viewing post in are rétro games still enjoyed ?
This is inherently subjective. IMO graphical style is separate from its graphics quality.
I am more attracted to quality graphics than gameplay, but good gameplay is what makes me stay. I think that goes for most people.
About your example specifically, the sprite sizes don’t really match. Some sprites are more blocky than others, which leads to a messy aesthetic. I think if you handle that, results will improve tenfold.