Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+1)
they are trying to claim they made something but instead what they really did was go to chat GPT or codex or something like that, and spend 5 minutes getting it to make a bunch of images and claim that this is worth $5 or $15.

While I agree that the content should be appropriately tagged, your claim also doesn't show reality as is, and won't be a surprise if many of those who upload AI assisted artwork decides not to apply the tag out of some kind of protest.

Sure, I don't know how they made their content , I can only talk for myself. And I will do that. Let me ask you first, how you think that works? You just say chatGPT 'hey made me a whole game' and it spit out a ready to play .exe file? Or 'hey computah... make me assets' and it spit out a bunch of .blend files? 

It doesn't work like that.  You may see in YT or other socials people showing they do stuff mostly with AI but those games are just more like basic prototypes of 'proof of concepts' rather than a fully playable and ready to ship games. And If the walk about the assets, same thing.

I used AI in some of the assets i upload here. Sometimes for up-scaling (taking a image of x resolution and produce the same in higher one without losing quality) sometimes for refinement (drawing the texture by hand (or well... traditional methods) and using AI, local AI BTW, to polish it to produce a more photorealistic albedo map, that i have to draw and re-refine over and over until reaching the desired result).

I'm recently using huanyang-3d (I think i wrote it wrong but anyway) to locally generate meshes from images. It's... okay, more or less, the meshes required polish and texturing work (it doesn't generate textured meshes) but I kinda developed a workflow that allows me to create a fully textured character in one afternoon more or less. How? by combining several separated steps. Creating a character image with limbs spread, removing the background, separating in pieces (head, hands, body, etc.), using the hunyuan-3d to generate a mesh from each image,then in blender do a remesh to lower the triangles count to something actually usable for each part, mark seams, unwrapping and all, then, also using another tool  i generate a basic texture over the topology heavy one and bake it to the lower one, then in Krita with the plugin 'Krita AI Diffusion' I fix the texture, redraw parts, edit the image overall to get the finished albedo map (and this is for just one of the body parts) then i have to make sure the texture fits right in the low triangles model -> re-modify what's needed (either mesh or image)-> re-verify, until it's good. Merge all body parts into one, sometimes using a topology bridge script I have (made with chatGPT). And each part, requires lot of work to do by hand, directly interacting with the PC, you know, 'effort'. 

So yeah, If many other devs are facing this same scenario, doing a lot of work to then be ignored or cursed upon or whatever, then it's fully understandable if they don't tag their work as AI assisted. And I didn't mention something more ironic, imagine doing a fully textured 3d model by hand, textures from baked shaders or photos, with normals and etc, but then having to tag the work as AI-assisted only because you used a small AI texture in a corner because you couldn't find a fitting texture anywhere and boing by hand was time-consuming or really hard. 

It's kinda understandable if some decides to ignore or not using the tag because in the end it doesn't feel fair.  Imagine doing a lot of work only to be ignored or attached based in a process the other person doesn't fully understand, nor understand at all. (And let's face it, some antis are bloody delusional at this point.)

I still believe everybody should appropriately tag their work. Slop is slop no matter the tool used but if you think that the issue with the slop or the showelware is because AI. Well... Is like blaming the moon for the night's darkness.
 

(2 edits) (+2)

cant agree more and want to add "asset-flip" which was the ai-slop of gone days.....back then buying or using free available assets was already the first step to the grave, which changed to AI.slop now, but you still can do great games with "effort" using one or the other, it all depends on your mindset, and avoiding ai tagging is somewhat the only option  you have, creating such kind of game, becasue the current trend is avoiding anything tagged with "AI" nomatter if it was one click output or used ethically,.....so its no wonder not everyone wants to disclose ai usag......i mean do you ask at mc donalds if they used gen-manipulated potatoes for their pomfrittes......haha

(+1)

You can now describe how you use ai in the disclosure, instead of needing to write it in description. It appears in the more info box below the ai disclosure.

Some of what you described sounds like procedural ai. But of course, most or all things a procedural ai could do, you could also do with a generative ai.

For assets, there are legal considerations. Generative AI must be disclosed without exception. No matter how trivial one would think it was. If the pixel was gen ai made, it needs to be disclosed.

Imagine a company buying assets and releasing the game on Steam and then getting kicked off the platform, because they violated terms of service by not disclosing that their game has gen ai in it.

For games, people do not like getting lied to. Claiming to have no gen ai in the game has to mean precisly that and not approximately. It is a trust issue. If you lie about ai, you might also lie about other things. And in turn the platform cannot tolerate this, because it will lose trust of the users.

Honestly, I do not even grasp why there are people buying ai assets at all. Either go buy human made assets, search for free human made assets or create your own ai assets. If you have no ai in your project to begin with, you downgrade the game by adding ai. And if you already are using ai, you should make your own. What's the point in creating a game, if you do not create the game.

(1 edit) (+1)

100% agree. I can play AI games, but will never download AI Assets, not even for free.  Most AI assets are the most slop, churning hundreds of assets. Personally, I would rather have a missing texture than an AI one.

The worst AI trends that need to be focused on are the "AI Agents" first. Then the selling AI source code, the rights to AI games (costing up to $10k), and the AI Assets. I don't want to use anything to make my game AI assisted.

Some of what you described sounds like procedural ai. But of course, most or all things a procedural ai could do, you could also do with a generative ai.

No. It's generative AI. I use chatGPT for programing assistance for example, or image editing sometimes and other tools I used are well know generative. Hunyuang-3D is a Img2Mesh model, Krita AI diffusion is a plugin for Krita that allows to use models like Stable Diffusion, z-image and flux inside the program (is something like a adobe firefly clone).

Honestly, I do not even grasp why there are people buying ai assets at all.

Because what matters in the end is not the tools used but if the assets itself fits the game. You can spend a month or a year creating a beautiful landscape or sprite sheet by hand with traditional methods. But if a potential user doesn't find it useful for whatever reason, then is not, and the effort you put in it won't change that.

 Third party assets are used because they save time. Even if in some cases you have to adapt such assets to your game's way of work, workflow, etc. And AI in many cases is time-saving depending what and how you do it. Yes, you may create an asset quick with AI yourself, but not having to do so is way quicker, and if you are working in a game alone. Having to work with programing, sound, graphics, story, etc. Then trust me, you wanna save time. This sounds obvious, but the work you put in one aspect is work you don't put in the other.  

Imagine a company buying assets and releasing the game on Steam and then getting kicked off the platform, because they violated terms of service by not disclosing that their game has gen ai in it.
For games, people do not like getting lied to. Claiming to have no gen ai in the game has to mean precisly that and not approximately. It is a trust issue. If you lie about ai, you might also lie about other things. And in turn the platform cannot tolerate this, because it will lose trust of the users.

Yes, i'm not saying otherwise. I can understand the motivations for a person to do X while not personally agreeing with it. I also believe people should be honest. 

What's the point in creating a game, if you do not create the game.

Even if using AI tools for different aspects you are creating the game to begin with. You had the idea, you spent time in front of the screen, you made stuff, create or search the assets, verify you have the right stuff, test mechanics over and over, and manually do stuff with tools that doesn't are AI, make decisions and so on. If you don't involve yourself enough, don't put any effort nor have a clue of what to do. Then you will end with a crappy game. Now, put effort, learn how and when use tools, plan stuff and overall involve yourself enough in the game's development, the story change. You don't create a bad game by using AI, it is bad because you made it bad. (or are we just going to pretend that everything before was great and rainbows and shovelware never existed?) 

You can now describe how you use ai in the disclosure, instead of needing to write it in description. It appears in the more info box below the ai disclosure.

Yes, but it doesn't matter. People won't care or simply will ignore the game at all because it has the tag 'AI-assisted' (or generated). And even, will attack you or the game even if you just used in for 10 lines of code. By the way, you have this game 'Big Walk' being bombed after the devs admited they used AI to fix a bug in Unity's engine after a Unity-dev Itself didn't wanted to give support. 


If you attack or punish people for the AI use, but the only way you have to know if if they are honest about it. Then in the end you are not punishing the AI usage, but honestly itself.

  

I have a problem with your points in favor of AI(p), and that is that anyone who disagrees with the use of AI(p) will think things like:

"AI-bros they do nothing but write long paragraphs with ChatGPT help to defend their point about their supposed good use of AI(p)"

What I mean by this is that however extensive and well summarized your points about the proper use of AI(p) may be, they don't generate empathy for certain people to understand you, not even when he tries to make it shorter.

(I have a feeling that when you reply me, it will be as long as the rest of your replies on the topic).

What I can agree with you on is that bad games and shovelware have always existed with or without AI(p). 

But the real point of this thread we are denouncing is not that AI(p) disappears, it is that they stop lying using the  "no generative AI" label.

Nah XD , I'm agree with you. I went off topic and I need to learn to write less. 

LOL! that very short reply left me speechless.

You are still the only one calling ai this way... ;-)

And what you said is not what I thought about that reply. We were not even talking about good use of ai or even the concept of good or bad applying to ai usage.

Except that you had also mentioned the same word, but you forgot it.  Although it should be emphasized that when I mention "AI(P)" it should be as an indication of why the word "AI" has been a marketing smokescreen for the new technological phenomenon.

That does not count. I did not use it for it's own sake. I basically quoted you - to ask what you even mean...

I guess most people assume you are translating into English and in your native language it is just called like that.

Actually, I meant that you mentioned it throughout your life rather a something recurring (which is something different).

AI(P) comes from the abbreviation of "Advanced Information Processors" (a more technical definition for AI or LLM).

My native language is Spanish, and its equivalent word is "(P)IA", and is abbreviated as: "Procesadores de Información Avanzada".

That's not a technical term for llm, nor for ai, nor for generative ai. It is not even a descriptive terminology for the tech.

The ai everyone is talking about is not processing information as a key point. It is generating things. Processing information would be old school procedural calculations. 

And the ai we are talking about explained to me, that not even in Spanish people use what you said. 

What does "Procesadores de Información Avanzada" mean? I am not asking for a translation of the words. I want to know if spanish speakers use that term and for what they use it.

Answer: “Procesadores de Información Avanzada” doesn’t appear to be a widely established term in Spanish. It sounds more like a coined name—perhaps for a company, department, or specialized technology—than a standard expression Spanish speakers would commonly use.

(3 edits)

Although it isn't a technical term for LLMs, its underlying intention is to find an alternative name for AI and to find a true meaning.

And not, "Procesadores de Información Avanzada" it's not a coined name in the Spanish vocabulary, I heard it in a COTEC documentary:

I recommend you turn on subtitles and go to minute 10 to understand it.

(+1)

Oh, it is refreshing to encounter people that are able to write more than a sentence or thought.

Mostly the image filtering and upscaling is things that are typically procedural. I suspect it is partially a marketing lie to call it "ai". And unfortunately, if they do not technically call it something like generative ai, large language model, diffusion techniques, trained neural network or something, than "ai" just means that an computer does some calculations. Which in this day could mean one of the gen ai thingies - or not.

And even if they use a generative ai for it, those things can be done without a network that needs a trained model.

About my opinionated decision tree, I still think it is pointless to buy ai assets.

If you make a hobby game, do whatever you want, but if you create the ai assets yourself, at least you have creative input.

If you already have gen ai in it, using free ai assets would not change the status, but actually having a budget and wasting it on ai? Come on. I think that's lame.

Since I am not a purist, that more information box would be helpful to me. The description of how ai was used. If I believe the description, of course. I do tolerate ai usage in hobby games. Up to a point. I detest ai agent made games. Or actual ai made games. That's funny once for the novelty. Like I would look at the artwork an elefant would draw. After that, it is pointless noise.

I get that code assistance is the tool of the trade, but vibe coding or writing the story with ai is just taking the essence away from game making. That's not why I play indie games. There is a ton of free human made games. No one needs ai made games. The indie game sector is over saturated even without ai games.

Oh, it is refreshing to encounter people that are able to write more than a sentence or thought.

No offense, but...

I suspect it is partially a marketing lie to call it "ai".

Like a ton of stuff named 'blockchain' or 'blockchain powered' 4 or 5 years ago... O_O fudge, where does time go?

Yeah, I'm agree with some of your points as well. But I don't wanna write another wall of text. 

(+1)

I meant what I said. People cannot argue. They cannot write. They get personally offended if someone does. They get emotional if someone attacks their arguments and they often do not even have an opinion based on reason, but pure emotion. They have the opinion first and then invent arguments. Or parrot things other people said.

This goes for just about anything. Mostly politics. It makes people easy to manipualte and that is happening far too often and on a far too big a scale.

Even in those ai topics. While ai is a huge topic that touches all aspects of life currently, we are still talking about ai in video games. I am usually seen as a pro ai person, just because I point out the weaknesses of the usual arguments like ethics and energy. Or how the browser that people use already has ai in it, so a vegan approach is pointless.

I focus on other things. And using ai for the very thing that makes indie game development a worthwhile hobby for developers, makes it uninteresting for the players. And if it is not a hobby, well, why spend money on a gen ai cash grab. There are tons of good indie games without ai.