Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Anyone been rejected by CrazyGames?

A topic by IndieDevUnity created 10 days ago Views: 643 Replies: 10
Viewing posts 1 to 7
(1 edit)

I submitted my Duck Hunter 3D game to CrazyGames and they rejected it.  I studied everything from the generic email they sent with the rejection and I made a lot of changes like onboarding and leveled sounds and made better game art and re submitted and was rejected again.  Obviously I think my game is the best game ever so I'm  upset but I went back to the drawing board and totally revamped duck hunting into arcade style with face paced rounds and lives and XP and extra lives and a fully automatic shotgun, flame thrower, grenade launcher, ray gun and controlled RPG.  It was that or just be mad.  Has anyone else had any experience submitting games to CrazyGames for review?

Here is a link to the updated game that was rejected for a second time.  I'm guessing it wasn't something they thought could make money but who knows they expect you to figure it out which after thinking about it makes sense.  Duck Hunter 3D by IndieDevUnity

I played the game and it seems for me at firs that I have to shoot the sitting ducks instead of flying ones, it's somewhat confusing.

Thanks for the feedback.  I just now got the revised version up with the player onboarding.  

CrazyGames rejects a lot on the first pass. Their FAQ lists the usual reasons as bugs, missing English, unoriginal content like clones or asset flips, content that misses PEGI 12, or stuff aimed at kids: https://docs.crazygames.com/faq/

They do let you resubmit after meaningful changes, which you've already done twice, so the generic rejection email is especially annoying. Their gameplay docs also put a lot of weight on originality of names and assets, and on landing players in the game with almost no clicks, so a duck hunt that leans into more arcade weapons and XP might still read as a familiar hunting shooter to their QA even if the pacing is better: https://docs.crazygames.com/requirements/gameplay/

If the email didn't name a concrete fix, asking support what failed the visual QA is worth a try before a third full rebuild. That vague "try again" loop is the worst part.

Thanks Jeremy.  Can you clarify, are you saying they still might reject an arcasde version that lands in the action is is non stop action?

It could still get rejected, honestly. Going arcade and dropping players straight into the action covers their "land new users in gameplay immediately" rule, but that's only one item on their list. Their originality line covers names and assets too, so a game called Duck Hunter 3D might still look close to an existing duck hunting game to a reviewer, even if it plays nothing like one.

The rest of their checks are pretty mechanical: text has to stay readable in small iframe sizes like 907 x 510, physics should behave the same at 144 Hz, and the game needs English. It's worth testing those before you resubmit. If you can, ask their support which check it actually failed, since that's the only way to know for sure.

Fingers crossed on the third try.

This was my rejection email.

Consider this feedback from our team regarding this decision:

The game did not reach the performance benchmarks during Basic Launch


(1 edit)

im  not sure but i remember ive also once submitted one of my retro-fps games to crazygames quite some time ago, but from what ive red i think it was due to the engine ive used, i think they only host gamemaker, gddevelop and only engines providing a web build i belive but im not sure....

but if you'Re out for some other sites to upload your game i can recommmend

https://gamejolt.com/@-X-ScornGames

https://conduitclips.tv/profile/-X-ScornGames

https://x-scorngames.newgrounds.com/

these 3 sites aint as good as itch, which we all love, but they are easy to use and have no "rejection" thing which could lead to annoyance, so maybe if you dont know them, check these links, they lead to my pages there, which would be really happy if in case you create a site there as well, would be incredible happy if you'd follow me after you created your page there :) of course ill follow back then...

best regards <3

I also got rejected from crazy games, can anyone please five me feedback https://www.crazygames.com/preview/65bd1595-0ab3-4c19-89a5-a9c55dd75943?gameBuil... 
the game is not perfect but I really thought it might pass.

(+1)

I guess all you do is click on the pipe and watch coins and sometimes jewels get pushed off and crushed and get the cha ching?