Thank you so much for sharing such deep insights! Knowing you have 7–8 years of professional experience explains why the pacing and 'quiet handholding' felt so seamless—that hidden safety net design is something I'm definitely going to study and apply to my own projects.
Also, hearing the personal story behind the core emotion (the pure magic of building your first game without real-world stakes) really resonated with me as an aspiring game designer here in Korea. I'd love to stay connected and keep learning from your work—best of luck with the jam results, and thank you again for the generous offer!
Since you kindly offered your perspective as a veteran in the industry, I’d love to pick your brain on a few more thoughts:
1. The Risk of Uninformed High-Stakes Choices (Beyond Just Having a "Pity System"):
While having hidden safety nets—like the revolver's ammo counter or the guaranteed 7 in the stat display—is a great backup system, my main concern is the irreversible punishment when a player's expectations clash with reality. Even if an upgrade theoretically helps generate 7s, if a player spends hard-earned currency on the revolver only to find its handling clunky and unusable for their playstyle, it feels like a wasted investment that actively hurts them.
Even more critically, take an expensive option like "Add another wave." A new player might think, "This is pretty easy, let me save up my 7s for the priciest option!"—only to walk blindly into a nightmare difficulty spike because the game gave zero indication of what kind of enemies would spawn. When a choice carries the risk of ruining a player's entire run due to vague descriptions, do you think keeping that information hidden is still worth the trade-off?
2. Low-Scope Narrative Cameos Outside the Frame:
Regarding my second point—I totally understand wanting to keep the focus on how the game-within-a-game evolves. However, when the player gets pulled back into the exact same cafe setting just to pick from 4 FPS-style options, it feels a bit static. Instead of a massive feature like a shop, what if you added tiny, low-scope narrative touches? For example, the heroine's reactions shifting slightly in the graphic, or even a 3D artist or sound designer suddenly popping in like a cameo(only for shadow)—saying something like, "Hey, that looks a bit bland, hold on I can help you to play on at grass." or "Um, the gun hit SFX feels weak, want me to throw in a better track?"—before quickly walking off. Even a brief, unexpected drop-in like that would make players go, "Whoa, a special event!" and feel like they're part of a real dev team, without needing heavy production resources.
From my own experience developing games, I know that animating character cleanly is definitely expensive—which is totally understandable. However, swapping out static background props, floor textures, or ambient audio/SFX is relatively cheap and low-effort in comparison....?
3. Letting the Player Choose the Number:
I actually think the "7" already works well within the game! Still, I couldn't help thinking that instead of locking it to 7, letting the player pick their own lucky number—almost like listening to the player's voice as a dev—could have scored massive narrative points. What do you think about that idea?
I'd love to hear your thoughts on these!