Playtest Feedback – Pieces of the Dynasties
First of all, thank you for letting me try your game.
These are my impressions as I played, written down as I experienced them. Some of my initial misunderstandings were cleared up as I continued playing, but I've included them anyway because I thought my first-time experience might be useful feedback.
1. First Impressions and Text Readability
I first tried the browser version.
The larger text looked fine, but some of the smaller text on the main menu was difficult to read. The difficulty labels such as "EASY", "MEDIUM", and "HARD" looked somewhat blurry, and text like "SELECT FACTIONS MAP SIZE AND DIFFICULTIES" was difficult to read because the text color seemed too similar to the background.
I played in fullscreen mode, but the game didn't fill my entire screen, leaving empty space on both sides. I'm not sure whether this contributed to the readability issue.
However, once I entered the actual game, the text was large and easy to read.
Later, I downloaded the desktop version, and the text on the main menu was much clearer there as well. So this might be a browser-specific issue.
2. Chess vs. Xiangqi – Initial Expectations
The concept of Chess vs. Xiangqi (Chinese chess) sounded really interesting to me.
However, when I started the demo, I could only select Chess vs. Chess. I was initially a little disappointed because I wanted to see how pieces from two different board games would interact.
Then I encountered a piece I didn't recognize, even though I know how to play chess. I eventually realized it was a Xiangqi Advisor.
Discovering that Xiangqi pieces could appear in the battle made me feel much less disappointed.
I'm Korean, and I'm familiar with both chess and Korean Janggi, so I thought I would have a reasonably easy time understanding the pieces. However, I still found some of them difficult to recognize.
3. Difficulty Recognizing Pieces and Understanding Their Rules
I couldn't recognize the Xiangqi Advisor from its appearance at all. I wondered why the game used such different visual designs instead of more recognizable representations of traditional pieces.
I also mistook an enemy Xiangqi Soldier for a Chess Pawn because they looked very similar.
At one point, two pieces that I thought were Pawns were facing each other. Then the enemy piece moved sideways and captured mine. I was completely confused because a Chess Pawn shouldn't be able to do that.
Only afterward did I realize it was actually a Xiangqi Soldier.
Similarly, I initially mistook another enemy piece for a Chess Bishop, but later realized it was a Xiangqi General.
Since the pieces have different movement rules, mistaking one for another made it difficult to predict what my opponent could do.
There was also a situation where I captured an enemy Advisor with my Bishop, but afterward I couldn't move my Bishop out of the palace. I couldn't understand why that happened.
Overall, I frequently found myself thinking, "Surely this move should work," only to discover that it didn't.
I don't think changing traditional rules is necessarily a problem, but I sometimes struggled to understand why certain moves were or weren't possible.
4. My First Battle
Toward the end of my first battle, my opponent had only their General left, while I still had my King and two Pawns.
I spent quite a while moving my pieces forward one square at a time, trying to finish the battle.
To be honest, I didn't find this particularly enjoyable.
Eventually, I reached a point where I couldn't figure out how to make any further progress, even with my two Pawns. I felt completely stuck.
I wasn't sure whether winning was actually impossible or whether I was missing something about the rules.
At that point, I wanted to stop and start over, but I wasn't sure what the difference between "Escape Battle" and "Resign" was.
I tried pressing Esc, but it only exited fullscreen mode rather than letting me leave the game.
I suspected this was a browser-specific issue, so I closed the browser version and downloaded the desktop client.
5. Understanding the World Map
After leaving the battle, I finally started to understand the overall structure of the game.
It reminded me of Heroes of Might and Magic.
Although I had selected Chess vs. Chess, I realized that the Xiangqi pieces I had encountered were apparently part of a neutral army rather than the opposing faction I had selected.
That explained a lot of my earlier confusion.
Unfortunately, I had lost most of my army in that first attempt and felt that recovering would be difficult, so I decided to start over.
6. Second Attempt – Desktop Client and Easier Settings
For my second attempt, I switched from the browser version to the downloadable desktop client. The text was noticeably clearer, especially on the main menu.
This time, I wanted to enjoy the game more casually, so I set the AI ELO to 100 and the world difficulty to Easy.
I was surprised when simply moving next to an enemy triggered a battle. I hadn't moved onto the enemy's tile, so I didn't expect combat to start.
Since the world map reminded me of Heroes of Might and Magic, I expected an encounter to work somewhat similarly, perhaps with a confirmation before entering battle.
Later, I noticed that the cursor icon actually changes when a movement will initiate combat. So the game does provide an indication, but I hadn't noticed it during my first encounter.
I also discovered that diagonal movement isn't allowed on the world map only after trying to move through an area that looked accessible diagonally.
The path appeared open to me, so I expected to be able to move through it.
7. Learning Something About Xiangqi
During this attempt, I encountered the Xiangqi Minister and was surprised that it moved exactly two squares diagonally.
I'm more familiar with Korean Janggi, where the Elephant moves one square orthogonally and then two squares diagonally.
I initially thought the movement was strange, but later learned that this is actually how the Xiangqi Minister moves.
It was interesting to discover that pieces with similar names have different movement rules in these games.
8. Finally Winning a Battle
I finally managed to win my first battle by checkmate.
By this point, I had started to understand the game's mechanics and overall structure much better.
After the battle, I returned to the world map and began thinking about my next steps.
I assumed that Pawns wouldn't be particularly useful compared to stronger pieces, so I decided to build a Barracks to recruit Rooks as soon as possible.
However, I didn't have enough food to build a Keep.
To gather more resources, I decided to attack another camp.
9. Why I Eventually Stopped Playing
Unfortunately, the previous battle had already taken quite a long time.
When I entered another battle and realized I would have to go through another lengthy fight, I simply didn't feel like continuing.
So I closed the game.
This time, I wasn't stuck because I didn't understand the rules. I knew what I wanted to do next, and I understood why I needed more resources.
But the thought of having to play another long battle was enough to make me stop.
I think this was the biggest issue for me personally. The overall concept is interesting, and I enjoyed gradually discovering how the different pieces and systems worked, but the battles felt quite lengthy.
10. An Additional Thought About Starting Pieces
Looking back, I think I would have played the game much longer if my starting pieces had been Pawns and a Rook instead of Pawns and a Bishop.
Personally, I find Rooks much easier to use effectively. Having one from the beginning might have made the early battles more enjoyable and encouraged me to continue playing.
Final Thoughts
I think the idea of combining Chess and Xiangqi within a Heroes of Might and Magic-like strategy game is genuinely interesting.
I also enjoyed discovering unfamiliar rules and learning how the different pieces worked.
However, I frequently had trouble recognizing pieces or understanding why certain actions were impossible. Some of that confusion disappeared as I learned more about the game, but the first-time experience could be clearer.
My biggest concern was the pacing of the battles. Even after I finally won and understood what I needed to do next, I didn't feel motivated to start another lengthy fight.
Of course, these are just my personal impressions from a relatively short playtest. I might have missed some explanations or mechanics along the way.
I hope some of these observations are useful. Thank you for making such an unusual game and giving me the opportunity to try it.