Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(1 edit)

Thanks for testing and giving such in-depth feedback!

the browser version is ported a monogame(which does not support browser directly) into browser, so maybe that causes some side-effects.
--
since you've played Janggi from before, I have a question, how should i present Xiangqi? 
this is a bit of a trouble for me, 
Showing the actual signs of the pieces can be tough for chess players and "scary", 
but perhaps i can try to find a middleground. 
--
Regarding the case of the Bishop was unable to move, it might be due to the flying general rule that Xiangqi has, which can cause some confusion. gonna see if i can improve the visual of this.
--
May i ask regarding the janggi elephant, since it moves so differently, I might add in an upgrade for minister, that makes it move like Janggi elephant. this would also make xiangqi be able ot become janggi instead. However, i can't call it elephant since the elephant exists in Tamerlane. does the janggi piece translate into something else? 
--
"Personally, I find Rooks much easier to use effectively. Having one from the beginning might have made the early battles more enjoyable and encouraged me to continue playing."
I think you are right here, i'd look into that, however, i'd make the starting armies more random.
--

Thanks for the feedback!

Thank you for taking the time to read through my feedback and respond so thoughtfully.

Regarding the Xiangqi piece designs, I'm honestly not sure. Maybe it's because I'm East Asian, but I don't find Chinese characters intimidating at all.

I wonder if Western players actually find Chinese characters intimidating, or if you might be worrying a little too much about that. Perhaps it would be worth asking some Western playtesters directly before deciding against traditional Xiangqi piece designs.

Personally, I think the traditional characters could even add to the game's unique identity.

As for the Janggi Elephant, I'm not sure making the Xiangqi Minister move like it would necessarily be an upgrade.

Personally, I find the Janggi Elephant rather awkward to use. Although it moves farther, its movement pattern is quite restrictive, and it can easily be blocked by other pieces.

Of course, its usefulness might be different in your game, but I think it might work better as an alternative piece rather than a direct upgrade.

If you do decide to add it, you could simply call it "Sang," which is the Korean pronunciation of the character 象.

Finally, regarding randomized starting armies, I think I would probably just keep restarting until I got a Queen or a Rook.

I wonder if a point-based system might work better. For example, players could receive a fixed number of points and choose their starting pieces, with stronger pieces costing more points.

That way, players could experiment with different army compositions from the beginning without feeling the need to reroll for a favorable starting army.

Of course, I understand that balancing such a system could take some work.

These are just my personal thoughts, so please take them as suggestions rather than requests. I hope they're helpful.

One more thing I wanted to mention: I really enjoyed learning about the differences between Xiangqi and Korean Janggi through your game.

For example, I already knew about the "Bikjang" rule in Korean Janggi, but I didn't realize that Xiangqi has a similar yet very different rule called the "Flying General."

What's especially interesting is that in Korean Janggi, the player in a losing position can actively use Bikjang to try to force a draw. In Xiangqi, however, the same situation is something you must avoid, since the two Generals aren't allowed to face each other directly.

I find it fascinating that such a similar situation can have almost opposite strategic meanings in two closely related games.

Discovering differences like this was genuinely interesting, and I think that's one of the unique charms of your game. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to learn something new.

(+1)

Sang is perfect! have some fun idea in mind for this! A choice here for which piece you want to recruit fits well! 

Thank you! 

Since you talked about xiangqi not available, i'll look into adding a demo with xiangqi instead.