The bewitched item is random. It'll start jiggling if you survive long enough, so then you need to drag it over to the safe.
Ahhh gotcha! I think I did it! Thank you!!
I gave the game another try and it seems like I still end up in teh same spot after I finish it? (the yellow circle in the middle with the stairs). Is there anything that I'm missing?
No, it means you made out alive. I added a text notice to show that. The yellow circle is a light bulb by the way. Sorry about the quirks.