HOLY CRAP THEY SCARE THE HELL OUT OF ME! I think this could be a very big game if you intend on adding more stuff to it. Maybe like FNAF, or BanBan!

WOW this game is amazing! Extremely polished for a game jam. If I saw this randomly posted while scrolling on itch, I would've assumed it took at least a month to finish. You guys really put in the elbow grease.

I loved the main menu and the web-based tutorial. I was able to understand the situation from the site alone, but the in-game audio tutorial was great too. 

ALSO I LOVE THE LOADING SCREEN, I WOULDVE MADE IT LAST FOR MINIMUM 5 SECONDS. 

The gun and blackout mechanic was really well done. The subtle tells the animals could give mixed with the pitter-patters during the blackout really creeped me out. At one point I was telling the animals to "SHUT UP" because I'd listen for sound cues and hear "MEEEEOWWW." I was really considering glocking down some of the loud ones regardless of if they were evil or not.

I was able to beat the game first try, but replayed it to see what would happen if you ran out of ammo or if you got caught at night. 

That leads me to my two points of order. To clarify, these aren't CONS nor complaints, just bullet points. First:

• Ending the game and telling the player they don't have enough ammo is somewhat boring.

• Imagine you're playing Mario and there's 30 seconds left on the clock. All of a sudden, right in the middle of the mission, the game calculates your moveSpeed * distanceRemaining and determines you can't make it and ends the game there. Or imagine you're playing Tic Tac Toe and your enemy sets up a fork. The game just ends saying "well you can't win now so it's over." Part of the fun is "fucking around and finding out." It would be more fun to let the player worry as to whether or not they actually killed an imposter with their second-to-last bullet, then finding out they messed up afterwards.
• I wish the ending occurred when you are truly out of ammo. You could have it so the lights flicker to black and when they turn back on, every animal is dead, your player turns around, and either one or two imposters is standing behind the player. This reveals who was evil, if you killed one of the imposters correctly, and is a fun little cutscene. I'm not sure how hard it is to do in Unity, but I think a cutscene like this in Godot would've been very doable with the AnimationPlayer.
• A lot of tension is built up but there isn't a climax.
  • Now this might be a moot point, but there's no jumpscare, or stinger, or shock moment. I found out that the way you die is via an explosion. That's kinda funny but it discounts some otherwise amazing tension that your team built up throughout the game. The pitter-patter, twitchy heads, etc shouldn't go to waste.

• Lastly, the scary moments were easily solved via bullet.
  • I loved how you could see the imposters' heads twitch in the dark, or hear them laugh, or how their creepy smiles would appear. The problem I have is that the tension and fear I felt was quickly solved by gun.
  • A game I like to play is called Deceit 2. In that game, you're fighting other players who are imposters. By day you have a gun, by night, everyone appears as a dark silhouette and you cant use your gun. That player can then transform into their monster form and chase you. I'm not saying you need to do all of that, but the lights and gun give the player safety. Taking one of those things away, but not both discounts the effort you put into trying to scare the player. A monster may scare me in real life. Hell, I might even brown note all over the place. But I'll tell you what. I won't be nearly as scared with a big-iron on my hip.

This game is very good i really enjoyed it I some how found the suspects by shooting random npc the graphics are very good grate work